TheCatSite.com › Forums › General Forums › IMO: In My Opinion › How much should government control how people spend their public aid?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

How much should government control how people spend their public aid?

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/me...lumn?track=rss

Okay, so I don't think there is any reason that gambling, drugs & erotic entertainment should be allowed on EBT cards (replaces food stamps). But, as the article points out, what about a man stopping by for a beer after a discouraging day of job searching? Or other human interests, such as a mom who buys a new outfit to wear at a job interview? Or a journal to record her adventures in raising a child? Or a disabled person taking their cat or dog to the vet?
Does/should government have the right to dictate that public assistance funds be spent ONLY on the essentials of living?? What do you think?
post #2 of 20
I believe that welfare recipients should not be allowed to spend their benefits on things like gambling, alcohol, but I also do not see how it can be stopped or even regulated much. They will find a way to do it as long as there are worthless humans sucking up the system.
Clothing, especially for a job, the occasional treat, or care for a pet that probably helps you health and cuts down on the need for meds and doctor visits are not really non essentials. Everybody needs a little joy in their life to make it worth living. It is the ones that wait on the check every month just to have a few days of pampering themselves at the expense of their kids that really make my blood boil.
Around the first of this month I had one of those worthless ghetto trash types in my cab. She was yakking on her very expensive cell phone about how she had sold her kid's food stamps "to get her hair and nails did." If I had picked her up or dropped her off at home, DSS would have been there THAT day. I was outraged!
post #3 of 20
I personally do think that EBT should be regulated. I have an EBT card and this month is the last month I get my food stamps because we are still under the limit for income this month. It helps alot, especially to help us pay off some past due bills we have while we dont have to pay for groceries. It is kind of hard to sneak anything past a food stamp only EBT card because you can not get paper goods, pet food, warm pre prepared foods (like the roasted chicken from Weis)...Stuff like that.

I will admit that I was guilty of 'selling my food stamps' but I bought my mom meats from Aldis ($30) so she would buy my dog food for me. I only did it once and now that BF got his job I told her that she doesnt need to buy the dog food anymore. I also dont use my food stamps for stupid stuff, I stock up on meats, stuff to make real meals not the kind in boxes. I limit how much junkfood we get like cup cakes cookies stuff like that. I try and shop smart while using that card especially to make it last a whole month sometimes you can get carried away with the 'good sales'.

I dont know much about the cash assistance but if someone uses their EBT card at an ATM (which you can do with cash assistance only) there really is no way to regulate what they spend that money on. I personally think that they should do away with it being ATM accessable to help cut back on the wasting of that assistance. I also agree 100% with drug testing for applicants also. Especially random monthly testing for people who get reviewed every 3-6 mths for their assistance. That would probably help cut out the mooches who use their assistance money to get drugs and stuff like that.

I dont enjoy the fact that we have had food stamps but honestly we needed them and it really helped alot. There are people who do use the assistance programs for good things. I actually threatened to remove BF off our assistance information because his dad wanted to use his medical insurance when we got it. If his intenstinal problems are that bad and he can afford to be buying cars and parts, and finish off his collection of Mystery Science Theater then he can afford to buy his own insurance plan. Oh wait thats right they just bought a camper to travel....thats why they cant afford insurance. Its people like that who abuse systems and really get me mad. Especially since it causes problems for people who try and get back on their feet. It goes along the lines where I feel the DMV should make allowances for graduates of DUI Treatment courts to allow them to get their license back upon drug testing, and graduation without revocation. Instead people who work hard to get on the right track (like BF) end up losing their license for an extra 5 yrs inhibiting them from finding a job in their line of work. Yet someone with 7 DUIs and 2 revocations on their file gets their license back in one year with no extra suspension. Its a bunch of crap IMO! Assistance programs and other county programs designed to 'help' people need to do some evaluating to try and 'fix' the problems they have.


Sorry got off on a tangent there and had a mini rant...But all in all they need to start regulating that kind of stuff!
post #4 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by catsknowme View Post
Does/should government have the right to dictate that public assistance funds be spent ONLY on the essentials of living??
Yes. As far as things (like pet food) that the government doesn't consider essential (but I do), there are ways around it --- like the poster who traded meat with her Mom for pet food. As a taxpayer, I'm fine with that.

On the other hand, someone making a similar trade to get her hair & nails done... WHAT??? That is totally outrageous!!!
post #5 of 20
This is a topic that bothers me a lot. My mother has been on one form of assistance or another since as long as I can remember. She suffers from Crohns disease, and has had surgery every few years. The doctors have basically said she is NOT allowed to work, though when she could, she is an incredibly hard worker. When I lived with her, my getting a job caused her to lose almost all of her food stamps- and I was 18. I moved out for this reason.

It bothers me that even though she really needs this help, and she uses it how it is meant to be used, she has trouble getting and keeping it. Yet, there are people out there (such as my fiance's sister) who are just to lazy to work, and get everything they need while popping out baby after baby.

I am a full believer that there should be drug testing for these things. Get rid of the ATM withdrawal on the cards, and monitor everything that is bought with that money. This should be bare necessities only. Watching my fiance's sister, I am to the point where I believe it shouldn't be possible to buy junk food with food stamps (which is all she buys).

For me, it goes along with the way that insurance systems and aid for college works. They help those that mess up, and leave the responsible people to fend for themselves. Get pregnant and drop out of high school and you get everything you need. I think it encourages laziness and a lack of hard work.
post #6 of 20
I wish I could write what I really want to but after typing it all out....It just got really nasty and mean and a little stereotypical. But needless to say I think that at some point certain people who expect things to get handed to them need to get a butt kicking handed to them and those honest people who are really trying to make it work and trying to do everything they can to be good people should get the pat on the back. Our county assistance is so beyond backwards they need to either fix it or do away with it period. Hopefully one day they will start seeing past just the 'application' and really start finding more thorough ways to screen people and better ways to moniter spending habits and most definately do away with atm withdrawels. Cuz if someone had their EBT card and was 'gonna go get their hair and nails did' I would take their card snap it in half and procede to knock some serious sense into their 'did up hair and face'. And thats the polite version...


I like the mean version better you could feel my anger vibrating thru the screen LOL
post #7 of 20
Its always gotten to me that people can use food stamps to buy potato chips and junk food, but they can't be used for toilet paper. To me, toilet paper is more of a necessity than junk food.
post #8 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Misty8723 View Post
Its always gotten to me that people can use food stamps to buy potato chips and junk food, but they can't be used for toilet paper. To me, toilet paper is more of a necessity than junk food.
I KNOW!!!! Really its a pain in the butt, I can buy cold hoagies, oreos popcicles and crap like that but I cant get paper to wipe my tooshie. If you dont have a kid or disability then you cant get cash assistance which is what they have for that kinda stuff. If you need help getting those kind of things you have to go to Savation Army or Red Cross. Its a bunch of bologna!
post #9 of 20
The Bible say "The borrower is servant to the lender". Once a person takes government assistance, they put the government in charge. They can decide to control it in whatever way they wish. What I think the government needs to do is exercise more control over how they give government assistance to begin with. For instance, I know a person who is on government assistance, has an 18 year old daughter who lives with her on government assistance. They already had a cell phone plan. Yet when they heard about these free phones, they applied and got themselves each a free cell phone from the government give away cell phone plan. But I guess that is another subject.
post #10 of 20
I believe that everyone getting welfare or food stamps should have to take and pass regular random drug tests to be eligible for aid. I am against deadbeats sitting on the porch using drugs or smoking pot. If they had a real job in many industries they would be subject to drug tests, so why not if they are getting government handouts?
post #11 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Misty8723 View Post
Its always gotten to me that people can use food stamps to buy potato chips and junk food, but they can't be used for toilet paper. To me, toilet paper is more of a necessity than junk food.
Good point. If I ran a non-profit organization, I would try to fill that silly rule (one of many many government flaws) at the local level. Toilet paper *is* necessary for daily life.
post #12 of 20
I think it should be regulated like WIC is. No convenience foods allowed.

I do believe that it should also cover basic needs: toothpaste, soap, laundry detergent, feminine products etc. I also think that veggie and fruit seeds and plants be included.
post #13 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by zohdee View Post
I think it should be regulated like WIC is. No convenience foods allowed.

I do believe that it should also cover basic needs: toothpaste, soap, laundry detergent, feminine products etc. I also think that veggie and fruit seeds and plants be included.
YES! I was going to mention WIC as well. "These are the foods you can get and nothing else". Basic needs like toilet paper, etc should be included and seeds is a wonderful idea.

I'm SO sick of getting behind someone at the market that is buying T-bone and porterhouse steaks and crab legs along with Doritos, snack cakes, tons of soda and paying for it with "the card" while I'm buying pork cutlets and chicken legs and searching for my coupons. Then, when I go to the parking lot they are loading everything into a new Lexus while I'm just hoping my car will make it back home before blowing up. It just BURNS ME!
post #14 of 20
I can't tell you how many times I've been in line at a grocery store and seen the person in front of me divide their grocerys into two piles. After they use food stamps or WIC (which ever one it is that they have to sign some form) for their food items, they pull out a wad of cash to pay for their beer and cigarettes.
post #15 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Telynn View Post
I can't tell you how many times I've been in line at a grocery store and seen the person in front of me divide their grocerys into two piles. After they use food stamps or WIC (which ever one it is that they have to sign some form) for their food items, they pull out a wad of cash to pay for their beer and cigarettes.
See now that kinda crap just burns me!! I cant stand that kinda stuff. Its the people who abuse the system that really just need to get kicked off and learn to fend for themselves.
post #16 of 20
I have never assumed that because there are some people abusing the system, that everyone abuses the system. I think most people know a story of abuse, but for every person abusing the system, there are a heck of a lot people out there that depend on it for their basic needs.

For that reason, I would be against mandatory drug testing simply because it would add undue cost to the government. How would this be paid for? How much money should the government spend to catch the small percentage of abusers?

I think that the restrictions on what is considered essentials should be examined, but to include things that are important, such as toilet paper, pet food, etc. I know there are people on this site who cut back on what they eat so that their pets can eat better food. I suspect that if they couldn't afford them at all, the alternative of rehoming them is really bad. Not everyone can anticipate loss of income when they adopt a pet.
post #17 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Momofmany View Post
I have never assumed that because there are some people abusing the system, that everyone abuses the system. I think most people know a story of abuse, but for every person abusing the system, there are a heck of a lot people out there that depend on it for their basic needs.

For that reason, I would be against mandatory drug testing simply because it would add undue cost to the government. How would this be paid for? How much money should the government spend to catch the small percentage of abusers?

I think that the restrictions on what is considered essentials should be examined, but to include things that are important, such as toilet paper, pet food, etc. I know there are people on this site who cut back on what they eat so that their pets can eat better food. I suspect that if they couldn't afford them at all, the alternative of rehoming them is really bad. Not everyone can anticipate loss of income when they adopt a pet.
I agree that not ALL are abusing the system, but why is it bad to weed out the ones that are? They are the ones that are taking (ie drug users who are waiting for their next paycheck from Uncle Sam so he can sell those and buy more drugs) from others that actually need it (ie the guy who has been trying to get a job but can't and doesn't qualify for food stamps), so I feel that drug testing is very valid. It may be a minority (or you may be surprised, but it's worth looking in to.

And, as much as I hate to say this...having a pet isn't a priorty to staying alive. Yes, pets help people in certain circumstances, but are they need by the government standards? Would I hate to separate someone from their pet? Yes, absolutely. But, in order for pet food to be included the owner should have to prove that the pet is spayed/neutered and up to date on shots.
post #18 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by calico2222 View Post
I agree that not ALL are abusing the system, but why is it bad to weed out the ones that are? They are the ones that are taking (ie drug users who are waiting for their next paycheck from Uncle Sam so he can sell those and buy more drugs) from others that actually need it (ie the guy who has been trying to get a job but can't and doesn't qualify for food stamps), so I feel that drug testing is very valid. It may be a minority (or you may be surprised, but it's worth looking in to.

And, as much as I hate to say this...having a pet isn't a priorty to staying alive. Yes, pets help people in certain circumstances, but are they need by the government standards? Would I hate to separate someone from their pet? Yes, absolutely. But, in order for pet food to be included the owner should have to prove that the pet is spayed/neutered and up to date on shots.
I believe science can prove the highlight wrong... ... UTD on shots has in two cases ended my animals lives early... thus I dont and my vet agrees ( yes they have had shots but I do not do yearly or every three after the booster)

Honestly I would imagine the cost to control the few problems would cost 100 times more than not... I love the drug test idea .. I would like to have a check of what type and yr of car is driven ( ie sorry but a new high end car can be traded for a more economical model... and how can you afford it and not food?..
post #19 of 20
People who abuse the system find ways around everything. You are only supposed to have a certain amount of assets per person in the household to be able to get food stamps. I am sure it would take a lot of household members to be legally able to keep your Escalade or custom motorcycle. Those are common in the low income housing around here. I can't believe the DSS office is right there and does not check in to it.
I know a girl that lives in a low income apartment that she pays 18 dollars a month for, because she has a handicapped child and elderly mother living with her, but gets no other help. The state will not help her go after the child's Marine father because they never married, even though she has paternity test results proving he is the child's father. She pays his medical bills and for his meds. Occasionally he will send her a few dollars, but not enough to be of much help. If the state was to find out about that, they might take away her apartment.
She works her butt off every day, 12-16 hours, has to pay out about $300 a week before she can make a dime for herself, but she does not qualify for help. She has no education and does the best she can driving a cab. They say her cab is worth too much for her to get any help, and it is a raggedy piece of crap. If ever anyone needed and deserved a little help it is this poor girl. She desperately wants to go back to school to try to make her life better, but cannot afford not to work. It is very hard to see her go through this and then go pick up someone with a new car in the driveway for a free ride to a free doctor's appointment. It must be really hard for her to have to do it.
It just makes me so angry to see stuff like this every day! No wonder this country is broke.
OK, will stop ranting now.steps down
post #20 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by krazy kat2 View Post
People who abuse the system find ways around everything. You are only supposed to have a certain amount of assets per person in the household to be able to get food stamps. I am sure it would take a lot of household members to be legally able to keep your Escalade or custom motorcycle. Those are common in the low income housing around here. I can't believe the DSS office is right there and does not check in to it.
I know a girl that lives in a low income apartment that she pays 18 dollars a month for, because she has a handicapped child and elderly mother living with her, but gets no other help. The state will not help her go after the child's Marine father because they never married, even though she has paternity test results proving he is the child's father. She pays his medical bills and for his meds. Occasionally he will send her a few dollars, but not enough to be of much help. If the state was to find out about that, they might take away her apartment.
She works her butt off every day, 12-16 hours, has to pay out about $300 a week before she can make a dime for herself, but she does not qualify for help. She has no education and does the best she can driving a cab. They say her cab is worth too much for her to get any help, and it is a raggedy piece of crap. If ever anyone needed and deserved a little help it is this poor girl. She desperately wants to go back to school to try to make her life better, but cannot afford not to work. It is very hard to see her go through this and then go pick up someone with a new car in the driveway for a free ride to a free doctor's appointment. It must be really hard for her to have to do it.
It just makes me so angry to see stuff like this every day! No wonder this country is broke.
OK, will stop ranting now.steps down
See those kind of situations suck big time because of the way the system is set up and the fact that they either wont or cant do anything to help people like her.

In my county unless you fear for yours or your childs safety you HAVE to apply for child support and the county will then force the potential father to pay atleast $200 of the paternity test if you need that done. I have noticed that in my county there is a lot that can be done for single mothers or low income families. However if you are a single male and need assistance its almost impossible to get assistance, especially medical.

What kind of gets to me about the system for determining eligability is how they base income guidelines. For one they base it off your pre taxed check not what you take home. Sorry but in my case the goverment is going to see most of that money they take out...Not me!

They also only take into account your utitlity bill and rent. We live in a run down piece of crap trailer that we have been investing our own money into to fix. They didnt take into account that we had to fix the oil tank just to get a company to deliver oil, or that we had to get the oil furnace itsself fixed when it broke down, or how about the new breakers we had to put in because some dumb butt decided to put the entire living room, hallway, stove and dryer on one breaker! We had to have our dryer replaced and our stove before we realized what the problem was and then had to go out and fix that. How about when we had to rewire the hallway light because when they replaced it they didnt wire it right and everytime you walked down the hallway the light would shut off. Its stuff like that where all they see is $200 a mth rent (after living here now I know why its so cheap haha), and a $200 electric bill that is $150 behind from when BF didnt have a job that we are slowly paying off. They wont even consider our cell phones part of a utility because we dont have a house phone we only use our cell phones, since they are in BFs brothers name also they wont consider it because its part of a family plan with three other lines on it. We even offered to have his brother write up a statement that says we pay him $120 a month for our service along with a copy of our individual lines costs. Nope they wont consider it. They wont take into account my car insurance because its not full coverage...Well I cant afford full coverage for a piece of crap car that keeps breaking down and no they wont take into consideration that for the 10 million appointments I have to show up for Ive needed to replace almost every sensor in my car because it wouldnt start and the alternator and battery so far. Whats going to break this week since I have to go into the office again on Monday.

Sorry this is turning into a me me me thing but this is just my personal dealings with the assistance office. It just makes me mad that I walk in there and see girls with 3 and 4 kids that barely look a year apart with an infant at their feet and pregnant. Not to mention the 'brand name' clothes they are wearing and jewelry covering their ears, neck and fingers, but their kids look dirty and skuzzy. Why help the over population more by being a baby machine to get more money from the goverment. Its the situations in my county especially the town that I live in where people are blatently taking advantage of assistance and dont give a flying fart that there are people who need the help because they cant afford to buy their own groceries because the 'pay' coming in is almost $200 less than what they need just to pay the bills let alone be able to buy toilet paper and stuff like that. Its the people that I run into in the assistance office in the morning that end up partying and drinking their butts off at night at the bar. Yes let me figure out who will buy us toilet paper while they are out paying for yeager bombs and captain and cokes. Let me figure out how to keep the cops from knocking on my door because Im scrambling money to pay fines while the electric company is calling because we cant afford to pay our full bill and its getting behind but you can go out and score a dime bag of drugs! Its these people that I run into on a regular basis who go out of their way to exploit theses systems put into place to really help people that need the help. These are the people that really grate on my nerves. There is so much help out there but so many limitations put on people who really need the help but heaven forbid they have a car to go out and look for a job or need the car for their job. Nope sorry you cant have that car gotta sell it and then report the profits that are going to clothe your kids, or buy medicine for your elderly grandparent who you have to take care of!


I have been giving this thread a lot of thought because of what Im dealing with now in regards to my assistance. Basically because the weather is nice and there is no guarentee on the hours my bfs company will work they are scrambling for as many as they can get. So he has gotten about one hours of overtime a day. They pay him overtime based on an 8 hour day not a 40 hour week. If he works only 40 hrs a week we still qualify for our assistance and would also be eligable for their assistance in helping us find a good used car, since Bertha is dying and we arent having any luck finding one that runs with barely any problems for under about $700. They program will help us find a car, and upon qualify would pay up to $800 of that car. Awesome right??? Wrong this program decided that not only will their guidlines be based off a gross income they also wont take into account any bills you are currently paying and or behind on. So thats out of the question. We also would still qualify for our food benefits which would help soooooooo much while we are trying to get caught up on bills that are behind or past due which is something we really are trying to get done. Because we dont go out to eat anymore we never realized how much groceries actually cost holy potatoes for two people we use every cent of that $367 a month. So now we are at the point where after this week our eligability for next month is determined and since BF got overtime again this week we are more than likely getting kicked off. What can you do though, they arent going to change everything they think works based on the faults found by a few people. These people that cheat the system are good at it and know how to play the system. Well sometimes I feel like a toad because if I didnt have a conscious I would have hid Bf having a job till Nov when our renewal was up and we could have kept the money. But Im not a toad and Im not going to cheat the system!

I hope that someday regardless of if they do drug testing or not, they find a way to better screen their applicants and make allowances or loop holes for people like in the quote above. Those kinds of people need the help so badly but there are so many restrictions and goofy rules that they end up jipping the people that need the help the most.

Ok enough of my ranting and raving.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: IMO: In My Opinion
TheCatSite.com › Forums › General Forums › IMO: In My Opinion › How much should government control how people spend their public aid?