WHY??? (vent)

dolores

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
May 8, 2010
Messages
3
Purraise
1
Location
Beautiful Portland Oregon
WHY do people insist on feeding OTHER PEOPLE'S cats? I have a beautiful 13-year-old tuxedo kitty who has been with me for 11 years. He was an outdoor cat before I got him, and I was never able to convince him to give up the great outdoors... and with 3 children running in and out of the house all day, I have by now given up trying; that choice is entirely up to him. He is also amazing at being able to get rid of his collar... I've spent a small fortune on collars and tags for this boy over the years, so of course I keep his microchip information up to date and have it scanned every time we go to the vet to make sure it's still scannable and hasn't become dislodged.

Anyway.

Every so often, despite the fact that he is clearly well-cared-for, some... well-meaning person (not what I wanted to say, LOL!)... around the neighborhood will start feeding him. It's usually someone who just moved in, because everyone else in a 4-block radius knows that's my cat. Cats are fickle. Frankly, Sol is very bright for a cat but if someone else offers him food, and it's different food from what he normally has at home, odds are he'll take it. He's especially a sucker for fish and ham. So then these compulsive cat-feeders apparently go, "Oh, look, he's hungry!" and they keep on feeding him, and pretty soon he's coming around for more treats and letting them pet him, and then they move it up to the next step... luring him into their house, and keeping him overnight.

THIS, my friends, really pisses me off. Who does this? Just because he's WILLING to eat your food and spend the night does NOT make him a homeless cat! And then I have to track them down, either by knocking on doors or by putting up posters, until they let MY cat (who is healthy and microchipped!) out of their house so he can come home.

THIS HAS HAPPENED MORE THAN ONCE.

One time he was missing for a week and my daughters were beside themselves with worry, and cried themselves to sleep every night until he came home. When he finally did (sans collar, sigh) I put a brand-new collar on him, with a tag that said "stop stealing my cat" and I got a phone call the next day from someone who claimed they thought he was "homeless". Yeah, right. Every neighbor around knows him, he's plump, sleek, and glossy, and he comes right up for pets and then leaves. Just like a stray cat, right?

One time he came home with a strange collar and a note taped on it that said "does this cat have a home? If not I'd like to help him find one, call 555-1212".

Ummmm... NO. I do not feel the need to telephone strangers to inform them that they cannot have my cat. I HAVE GIVEN HIM A PERFECTLY SUITABLE HOME FOR 11 YEARS. They are freaks who feed other people's cats. I don't want to talk to them! I put a new collar on him, once again, with a tag. (I keep extras on hand, because he is SO good at getting out of them!) You would think it would end there, but I got a call from the lady who had been feeding him, trying to insinuate that, because he liked her food, I must not be taking adequate care of him.
I had to go to her house (with my daughters!) and pick him up in person. She was... um... pretty interesting. Sigh.

Completely unhello.

He's getting on in age and I need to be careful about what he eats so he can stay healthy. LORD only knows what they're feeding him, what with their horribly misguided notions. Probably canned tuna. I feel like anyone who really knows cats and has experience with them would not mistake a well-fed indoor/outdoor cat for a stray or start feeding someone else's cat, so I am concerned about how much these people know... and what if someone shuts him up inside and then moves away with him? I wish I could just keep him in! I've tried many times, but the longer I keep him inside the more determined he becomes to get out... I know, for that reason, that he'll always come home to me, as long as nobody takes him out of the neighborhood.

Sorry for the long vent, this is just freaking me out! I've been in this neighborhood for six years, and the last time he went missing I put up posters and got supportive calls from a lot of neighbors saying they know him well and would keep their eye out for him. He is gone again and I am pretty sure the same lady, two blocks away, has him. I am SO dreading going to pick him up and dealing with her again!

Has anyone else had this problem? Any ideas on how to discourage it? I don't think it would be a problem if I could only keep him from losing his collar, or keep him inside entirely, but... so far... those seem to be impossible dreams!
 

krazy kat2

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 14, 2001
Messages
8,085
Purraise
41
Location
Somewhere in Georgia
As long as he goes outside, some well meaning person is going to feed a friendly cat. I understand how it can drive you nuts, not always knowing where he is, but at least people are trying to look after him. He must be a real charmer.
 

meowcat

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
May 8, 2010
Messages
21
Purraise
1
Location
UK
Maybe there is something at home he is not happy about. Or he is hungry when he goes out. Don't any of your nieghbours tell them he is yours? I know Vets here who will tattoo your telephone number in the cat's ear so people can always ring you up, and check. But cats are fickle. And they will go werever they want to if they are let out. Which puts them at risk from people who sell cats to research labs for money. I heard that you can get £300 per healthy cat, in blood money for them too. Which is appalling, and as bad as murdering them, in my opinion. Hope you find a solution. I'll pray for your cat if you like.
 

darlili

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Oct 16, 2007
Messages
3,310
Purraise
14
Location
Illinois
My first thought on reading this is you could be blessing these 'busy bodies' who are doing their best to help an uncollared cat that clearly is happy eating their food and staying at their house - and go out of their way to try and find this cat's home, if any.

I'm guessing you're angry in that you can't keep the cat in the house, or collared, but what a wonderful bunch of people live in your area. How exactly are they supposed to know this cat has a home? Can you find it in your heart to bless these angels who, rather than ignoring this cat, or worse, hurting him, are doing the best they can?

And, how old are your kids? Can they help you in keeping doors and windows closed a bit more? My guy is a door dasher too - but he can't turn the knobs himself.

PS - I hope you did call the person who left a number on his collar - I'm sure he/she was worried, just as you are when your guy makes a break for it.

Good luck in finding your guy today, and a way to keep your boy closer to home - but truly he must be a friendly cat, and how lucky you are to have neighbors who watch out for a lost cat.
 

blueyedgirl5946

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
14,596
Purraise
1,699
You are not going to be able to control your neighbors. But you can control your cat. The only solution is keep him home. Maybe you could instruct your children to not turn the cat outside. Have your thought about a possible cat enclosure outside where you could put your cat for some outside time. The other thing is when your cat is free in the neighborhood, there is always the possibility he could have access to pesticides, rodent poison, fertilizers, etc. I do hope you find a solution. Apparently you have a lot of neighbors who are cat lovers.
 

white cat lover

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Nov 17, 2005
Messages
22,206
Purraise
35
Many people will feed & take in a cat found wandering, because oftentimes they do not have an owner. It is often hard to tell if they are well fed stray cats, or someone's housepet.

Do you have the ability to build some sort of outdoor enclosure for him, as a compromise? Then he would as access to the great outdoors, as he demands, and you could have peace of mind.
 

Willowy

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 1, 2009
Messages
31,893
Purraise
28,300
Location
South Dakota
My goodness. The anger in your post.

My family had an outdoor cat, very friendly, everyone in the neighborhood knew he was ours. He was actually a member of the church across the street, LOL. He had a picture in the member's guide and everything! (note: not our church!)

We tried to keep a collar on him but he lost them regularly. There was always a replacement but sometimes he'd go a couple days without I.D. He was NOT happy as an indoor cat, so if someone tried to keep him in their house (he was allowed in several neighbor's houses) they found that out pretty quick (he wouldn't use a litterbox and would scratch at the door when he had to go). If he had ever come home with a note I would have been glad someone cared enough about him to find his home.

Now, I keep cat food out all the time for my ferals. I do not monitor who eats it. If the neighbor's cat comes by and eats it, that's not my problem. Plump, sleek and glossy cats show up all the time because people DUMP them. Neutered, de-clawed, fat, etc. When that happens I put posters up and put a collar on the cat asking his owner to call me. NOBODY has ever called me. So I find a new home for the cat. Friendly cats can't be allowed to run homeless all over the place.

How are they supposed to know he's your cat? How are they supposed to know you actually care about him? I think you have a pretty good bunch of neighbors. People who really care about cats.

What kind of collar do you use?
 

meowcat

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
May 8, 2010
Messages
21
Purraise
1
Location
UK
Originally Posted by Willowy

What kind of collar do you use?
I don't think putting a collar on them is a particularly good idea. Collars mean they can easily be caught, by anyone. Collars make it easy for Cat thieves to snatch healthy Cats. But if they've got no collar, they can at least fight if someone grabs them.
 

meowcat

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
May 8, 2010
Messages
21
Purraise
1
Location
UK
Originally Posted by Dolores

WHY do people insist on feeding OTHER PEOPLE'S cats? I have a beautiful 13-year-old tuxedo kitty who has been with me for 11 years. He was an outdoor cat before I got him, and I was never able to convince him to give up the great outdoors... and with 3 children running in and out of the house all day, I have by now given up trying; that choice is entirely up to him. He is also amazing at being able to get rid of his collar... I've spent a small fortune on collars and tags for this boy over the years, so of course I keep his microchip information up to date and have it scanned every time we go to the vet to make sure it's still scannable and hasn't become dislodged.

Anyway.

Every so often, despite the fact that he is clearly well-cared-for, some... well-meaning person (not what I wanted to say, LOL!)... around the neighborhood will start feeding him. It's usually someone who just moved in, because everyone else in a 4-block radius knows that's my cat. Cats are fickle. Frankly, Sol is very bright for a cat but if someone else offers him food, and it's different food from what he normally has at home, odds are he'll take it. He's especially a sucker for fish and ham. So then these compulsive cat-feeders apparently go, "Oh, look, he's hungry!" and they keep on feeding him, and pretty soon he's coming around for more treats and letting them pet him, and then they move it up to the next step... luring him into their house, and keeping him overnight.

THIS, my friends, really pisses me off. Who does this? Just because he's WILLING to eat your food and spend the night does NOT make him a homeless cat! And then I have to track them down, either by knocking on doors or by putting up posters, until they let MY cat (who is healthy and microchipped!) out of their house so he can come home.

THIS HAS HAPPENED MORE THAN ONCE.

One time he was missing for a week and my daughters were beside themselves with worry, and cried themselves to sleep every night until he came home. When he finally did (sans collar, sigh) I put a brand-new collar on him, with a tag that said "stop stealing my cat" and I got a phone call the next day from someone who claimed they thought he was "homeless". Yeah, right. Every neighbor around knows him, he's plump, sleek, and glossy, and he comes right up for pets and then leaves. Just like a stray cat, right?

One time he came home with a strange collar and a note taped on it that said "does this cat have a home? If not I'd like to help him find one, call 555-1212".

Ummmm... NO. I do not feel the need to telephone strangers to inform them that they cannot have my cat. I HAVE GIVEN HIM A PERFECTLY SUITABLE HOME FOR 11 YEARS. They are freaks who feed other people's cats. I don't want to talk to them! I put a new collar on him, once again, with a tag. (I keep extras on hand, because he is SO good at getting out of them!) You would think it would end there, but I got a call from the lady who had been feeding him, trying to insinuate that, because he liked her food, I must not be taking adequate care of him.
I had to go to her house (with my daughters!) and pick him up in person. She was... um... pretty interesting. Sigh.

Completely unhello.

He's getting on in age and I need to be careful about what he eats so he can stay healthy. LORD only knows what they're feeding him, what with their horribly misguided notions. Probably canned tuna. I feel like anyone who really knows cats and has experience with them would not mistake a well-fed indoor/outdoor cat for a stray or start feeding someone else's cat, so I am concerned about how much these people know... and what if someone shuts him up inside and then moves away with him? I wish I could just keep him in! I've tried many times, but the longer I keep him inside the more determined he becomes to get out... I know, for that reason, that he'll always come home to me, as long as nobody takes him out of the neighborhood.

Sorry for the long vent, this is just freaking me out! I've been in this neighborhood for six years, and the last time he went missing I put up posters and got supportive calls from a lot of neighbors saying they know him well and would keep their eye out for him. He is gone again and I am pretty sure the same lady, two blocks away, has him. I am SO dreading going to pick him up and dealing with her again!

Has anyone else had this problem? Any ideas on how to discourage it? I don't think it would be a problem if I could only keep him from losing his collar, or keep him inside entirely, but... so far... those seem to be impossible dreams!
You could try putting butter on his little paws. My Grandmother used to swear by that. (But she was riddled with oldtimers, and sometimes thought my Grampy was "Jim from the War")

But when I asked her about it, she thought I meant putting butter on "Jim from the war's" feet, and got quite agitated, when she thought it might bring him home. From the war, presumably.

I wouldn't even mention it, but her cat never played away from home.
 

Willowy

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 1, 2009
Messages
31,893
Purraise
28,300
Location
South Dakota
Originally Posted by MeowCat

I don't think putting a collar on them is a particularly good idea. Collars mean they can easily be caught, by anyone. Collars make it easy for Cat thieves to snatch healthy Cats. But if they've got no collar, they can at least fight if someone grabs them.
The collar should be a breakaway type. So if anyone grabbed it it would just snap off in their hand. And how would someone know if the cat is owned or not if it doesn't wear a collar and tags?

But some snap easier than others; that's why I asked. The easy-snap kind get lost easily.
 

carolina

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 17, 2008
Messages
14,759
Purraise
215
Location
Corinth, TX
Originally Posted by MeowCat

I don't think putting a collar on them is a particularly good idea. Collars mean they can easily be caught, by anyone. Collars make it easy for Cat thieves to snatch healthy Cats. But if they've got no collar, they can at least fight if someone grabs them.
IMO a cat that goes outside should have a collar at all times - that can make a difference in between life of death. Of course it should be a safety/ break away collar, but it should have pets name, owner's contact information, and probably rabies tags.
About your logic on cat thieves? Well... It is not really easy to catch an unknown cat outside, collar or no collar. Second, you can recognize a healthy cat with or without a collar - at least I can...
IMO people would be much more inclined to take in a a cat without a collar than one who had a collar - and in that case there goes your kitty... You would never see it again. (this is for anybody not thieves) Also, if something happens to it, how would anybody let you know? If someone took it to the pound - how would you know? There are just so many reasons to have a collar, and really no reasons to not have one, IMO...
 

maxiecat03

TCS Member
Adult Cat
Joined
Apr 25, 2008
Messages
199
Purraise
1
Location
Ottawa, Canada
I put out food for the strays....and they need the food and they eat it. I can't help it if a pet comes around to eat. They don't generally eat alot because they've been fed at home.

This might be the same idea as your neighbours...they put out food for stray cats who have no home to go eat in.

As others have said, it's your responsibility to keep your cat in....and stop complaining about what the neighbours do. If anyone of my neighbours came to me complaining that their cat ate at my house, I would have a lecture for them about keeping their cats in. I don't believe that your neighbours are deliberately feeding YOUR cat!!!

Put some of that venting energy into training your family on how to enter and leave the house without letting the cat out. It is possible. My two cats are indoor cats who want to go out...and we know how to avoid letting them out. Your cat is much safer and healthier by remaining indoors. You won't have to worry about what he's eaten, or losing his collar. Three benefits right off the top of my head!!
 

colorpointcat

TCS Member
Adult Cat
Joined
Apr 18, 2010
Messages
183
Purraise
1
Location
auburn ny
I feed all cats even the ones that look nice and plump and probably have a home. I dont believe in outside cats only because i live in a city and there are loose dogs/coyotes and cars its dangerous. Even in the country i didnt believe cats belonged outdoors. Its just too dangerous. Be thankful you have such nice neighbors.
 

icklemiss21

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Aug 14, 2005
Messages
16,465
Purraise
20
Location
in the land of poutine and ice
If I see a cat outside without a collar, it does get fed, caught and taken to the shelter - you are lucky they are just feeding it and not dropping it off at a shelter where you get fined each time
 
Top