TheCatSite.com › Forums › Our Feline Companions › Behavior › Lost the four year battle, worried about a new battle...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Lost the four year battle, worried about a new battle...

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
I'm finally at my wit's end with Toby. Four years ago, I got another cat, Trina. I'd thought he'd be okay, only being five and having lived with another cat for the first three years of his life, but nope. He liked being an only cat.

The following isn't actually relevant to my question, I'm just really sad and venting..

Then the innappropriate peeing began. I've tried everything; he's only ever had one UTI (which was last year, well into this behavior). The solutions worked well until I moved into a smaller apartment; then the things I did that worked previously made it worse, cleaning the litter several times a day, using cat attract, using feliway, enzyme cleaners.. it's just gotten worse and worse.

Once we moved into the smaller apartment, he started peeing on the extra bedroom's carpet. So we locked him out in hopes he'd get the message. Then he started with the bathtub, then transferred to the rug, so we locked him out of there. Any time he'd get into my room (or I'd let him in and keep an eye on him), he'd bolt and immediatly pee (not spray, he squats). He'd run under my bed and pee. So we've locked him out of everywhere except the main room, where he was okay it seemed since there was no carpet (although he's been peeing in my boots and shoes).. and yesterday, he peed on Trina's cat tree, so I put tin foil over that after using enzyme cleaner. Then he decided to use a receipt I left.. on the couch.

I think it's a territory thing; the more we kept him out of the places he liked, the more he couldn't sleep with me, and the less he saw of me since I'm so busy, the more he's done things deliberately to me, like marking MY clothes and MY shoes, etc. Not the roomies.

It's not fair to my room mates.. And it's breaking my heart, I can't sleep.


Tomorrow, Toby goes to the vet to get checked for a UTI (just in case, but I don't think so from his history), and then to go live with my mom and aunt, who have all hard-wood floors, leather sofa, and no carpet anywhere. I'm going to buy a huge litter box and a cheap rug to put in a corner of it to encourage him to use it there.. but hopefully he'll be happier there, as an only cat, with more space, and with my aunt who ADORED him when we all lived together when I was growing up, and with someone who's always there to pet him.. I'm now a full time student who works about 30 hrs a week on top of it, so maybe it's an attention deficit, especially since he's not allowed to sleep in my room anymore...

I'm worried about Trina now, though. Trina has ALWAYS had other cats around; the first year of her life she lived with a hoarder and had about 50 others to keep her company, then when we got her, she had five kittens. Whenever I fostered over the years, she's always adopted whatever gaggle of kittens I've had within a few days.. and of course, has always been with Toby.. Even though he hates it, she always tries to play and snuggle.

Trina is the opposite of Toby; she uses her litter box, scratches where she's supposed to, is loving, affectionate, and essentially the perfect cat. I'm worried that without another cat to love, to keep her company, she might become destructive, especially with me being so busy.

Is this a legitimate concern? How likely is she to spring up with behavioral problems without a companion? What can I do to make this transition from multi-cat household to single cat household easier on her? Am I just overreacting?


I'm sorry this was so long.. It's 5 a.m. and I can't sleep. I'm trying to do the right thing with my cats for both of their happinesses, since Toby is obviously not happy.. ugh. Anyway, thank you for reading and your time.
post #2 of 4
:Im so sorry things have come to this. But at least you know where Toby will be and can see him whenever you want to. It is obvious you are agonizing over your decision, and I can totally understand that. I would be too. Anyone would who truly loves their animals.

Your other kitty, Trina actually may welcome a bit of a respite from the chaos in which your life has been. Try not to borrow trouble until you see how she reacts. Give her as much extra attention as you can. Maybe a new climbing tree or new bed. My cats love new stuff! It seems to make any changes in their lives secondary to the new thing they have to play with. Kind of like little kids!

I hope Toby gets over his behavior problems with more attention at your aunt's house. That should bring you some comfort knowing he is well taken care of.

Please keep us posted as to how Toby and Trina are doing. You have certainly gone above and beyond trying to keep Toby. Don't be too hard on yourself. Not everyone would take such pains to remedy a bad situation.
Be assured you did all you could. Take care
post #3 of 4
You're doing the right things. I'm betting that Toby will thrive as an only cat in an affectionate environment, and Trina will enjoy living in a less stressful environment, too. Cats pick up on tensions even when they aren't directly involved.

You've been through the wringer. Congratulations on devising a great solution that sounds like a net positive for Toby and your family. Many people abandon such cats at a shelter rather than find the cat a workable new home. You honor your commitments.

Give Trina a little time to adjust. If it turns out she's lonely as an only cat, it may not result in behavioral problems. She might just mope and demand more attention. And chances are you can find her a new cat friend who won't have behavioral problems, either. You had a really unusual experience. Here's hoping you have paid your dues!
post #4 of 4
I doubt Trina develops problems after Toby leaves, but she may become depressed. She'll need extra attention and play time from you when you're there. But if she has a problem, can you adopt another kitty for her to play with? If you adopt from a shelter, you can ask for a cat that is cat-friendly.

As to Toby, I'm so sorry. But you may want him to go to your aunt's with more than one litter box, because if he peed in the tub, he'll pee on hardwood floors. Sometimes adding more litter boxes helps. Also, if your Aunt can afford it, she should try using Cat Attract litter. This also OFTEN helps correct inappropriate peeing behavior - Cat attract certainly does attract the cats.

And because of the stress of moving, I suggest she spray the home with Feliway before he even arrives - this should help reduce the stress of moving. Even though Toby hasn't been happy, it is his territory, and changing territories is stressful. Also, your Aunt needs to know that if he pees outside the box, it must be cleaned with an enzyme cleaner. This is the only thing that removes the scent of pee to the kitty, otherwise the scent encourages him to continue to go outside the box.

In fact - you may want to get a black light and go through your apartment to make sure you've cleaned up all the places he peed outside the box, and if you haven't used an enzyme cleaner, you really ought to. The best one we've used is Nok Out, which you can only purchase online: http://www.nokout.com.

And since he does seem stress prone, your aunt may also want to consider using Bach's Flower Essences with Toby: http://www.bachflower.com/Pets.htm She can add a few drops to his water dish(es), and dab a little behind his ears, on the back of his neck, at the base of his tail, and under his chin.

for Toby.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Behavior
TheCatSite.com › Forums › Our Feline Companions › Behavior › Lost the four year battle, worried about a new battle...