Need advice on women (a confused man!)

ancientsanskrit

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2008
Messages
115
Purraise
18
Location
In TX, but will always be a Michigan-boy.
Hi ladies, consider this a mild rant, vent and plea for advice!


Background info: I'm a 26 years old typical urban (metro!!) guy from the North. The girl in question is a 28 yrs old southern belle. An important fact is that she ended a 1 year relationship with a guy back in January '08. So the girl in question is in my Master's program. Previously, we weren't really good friends, just acquaintances. I asked her to dinner one night, and we just hit it off. We spent almost 4 hours talking. At the time she was looking for a place to live and I was looking for roommate to split my rent. At the time I indicated that I was dating, but not looking for a relationship per se.

Anyways, she moved in, and we hit it off. We became almost inseparable for two months and did everything together. We could talk almost endlessly; she loves my intellect and she stimulates me, too. I've learned through my years of relationships that as I mature, I want to build a foundation/friendship before pursuing a relationship.

We became flirty. She would almost egg me on to hit on her, yet be defensive at the same time; sort of throwing up mixed reactions. Well, apparently this worked on me and I started developing feelings towards her. I never intended to, but it just sort of happened. I'm not infatuated with this girl, but I do care for her.

Come October, I opened up to her and told her I had feelings for her. Now typically, I would either wait for a girl to open up to me, or somehow sneak a kiss or something alike, but I felt as this girl was more mature, she would rather have a guy open up to her.

It all blew up in my face. I think opening up to her scared her away. In a very brief conversation with her regarding my feelings for her, she mentioned that she does not feel the same way. Now normally, this would cue me, "okay this girl doesn't dig me, time to move on". However, moving on has been hard on me based on the mixed reactions she still gives me. Case in point, when I head out at night, she will constantly ask me where I'm going/what I'm up to. She is consistently listening in on my phone conversations, and will even ask "who I was talking to."

We now do nothing together, except for some odd cases. One night we went to a bar together for a mutual friend's bday. A girl started hitting on me, and I just casually talked with her. The roommate started asking me what I was saying, and I poked her legs and taunted that it was none of her business. It ends up girl hitting on me knew the roommate, and the roommate went over and had a conversation with said girl. Said girl walks away, and I ask what's going on with roommate and receive a "I don't play games." Well, the next day, roommate hounds on me to go to lunch with her. This after asking her to do something for the longest time since we stopped hanging out. It almost seems she is playing like she's a hard to get commodity, or sees other women hitting on me and becomes interested....it really does spin my head trying to figure what the heck is going on here.

The red flag. Recently, she started hanging out with her ex-boyfriend of two relationships past. These two have had a long relationship (I believe they've known each other for 10+ years). Oftentimes, when we talked, she would indicate how he was immature and not a good guy. Yet, she is hanging out with this guy quite a lot. The major red flag is what I may be perceiving as not coming home at night. I'm not going to speculate anything, but these are major red flags to me. Yet, consistently she will almost make it known to me that her intentions are to hang out with him when she is going out. I never ask her where she is going, but she'll make it known to me.

I've never had such a hard time with a girl before. Usually, most women are somewhat open with me to their feelings. I'm starting to let go, and move on. This rant is really due to an incidence tonight. I met a really interesting girl at Barnes and Nobles, and we decided to go for coffee and talk this evening. When heading out, I got "the inquisitive eye" from her. I kept noticing her glancing at me while trying to look occupied watching TV.

Sorry for the longest post I've ever made. I do enjoy this girl's company, but the fact that she is either playing hard to get, perhaps playing games is really turning me off to her. If she would be open and just tell me flat out she didn't care for me, I would be able to bare it and move on. My female friends tell me to give her time, as I have only known her for a good 4 months (as acquaintances for about a year), yet something tells me this girl just doesn't know what she wants. She definitely has some insecurity issues, and not to sound haughty or anything, I am the first true gentleman she has had in her life. It's really confusing, and the complexity of it is compounded by the fact that we live together. My male friends tell me to move out and move on!!! On one side, I think they are partially right, but the "nice guy" in me wouldn't allow me to do that in fear of being a real jerk, since she just moved in a few months ago. It does drive me nuts having feelings for this girl and having her act upon her ex. I try not to let it show, and have been pursuing other avenues to see what's out there. Given that I see this girl everyday, it makes it just that much more difficult, though. I definitely don't respect her toying with me should she truly have feelings and is playing some sort of agenda.

Anyways, sorry for a very long rant. If you have opinions, not including "this post is too long," I'd like to hear 'em. I know love is blind, and it seems I'm quite myopic right now and want to hear what others have to say.
 

ut0pia

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 25, 2008
Messages
5,120
Purraise
34
Sounds like the now cliche phrase "she's just not that into you"...
Also, she obviously isn't looking for a relationship, just looking for flirting or random play and doesn't want to complicate the friendship you already have. If she wanted it badly enough though, she'd be willing to risk it...
It sounds like you're a really nice guy, and I have to applaud you for being so analytical of the whole situation!! Not many guys do this..but I'd agree with your friends, stop living with her and move on, playing games is so not worth wasting your time ..
You have to remember also that even if she isn't really interested in you, she may still be jealous of other girls you might start dating...She could just want to remain on the top list of important females in your life..
ETA: the reason why I say that she isn't into you is because I no longer believe people act logically when it comes to relationships, but rather just act on their emotions.. so I don't think that the fact that she could be confused about what she wants is the reason why she hasn't returned your feelings, although that's a possibility. But, if you live together and she likes you, no confusion would be able to stop her from acting on it IMO..
 

swampwitch

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2006
Messages
7,753
Purraise
158
Location
Tall Trees & Cold Seas Vancouver Island
Sounds to me like she doesn't know what she wants. She's also baiting you to see how much you want her. I'm guessing your indifference isn't helping her decide if she wants something more permanent with you or not. I know you told her you have feelings, but it sounds like she wants to see you prove it on a daily basis.

She.. could just be kind of nuts. Sometimes a little nutty is not such a bad thing (my husband would probably tell you) but sometimes it's crazy to live with and not worth it.

Have you asked her what's going on? "I don't play games" doesn't match her actions. I know that when something doesn't make sense, we aren't seeing the whole picture.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #4

ancientsanskrit

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2008
Messages
115
Purraise
18
Location
In TX, but will always be a Michigan-boy.
Originally Posted by ut0pia

But, if you live together and she likes you, no confusion would be able to stop her from acting on it IMO..
My sentiments, exactly. I've never gotten to the bottom of it, but why would she move in with me? I've never had a girl so quickly just move in with me. Only situation was from a long-term relationship. It is a unique situation, and I feel she may just be using me for her own security feeling. Can any female shed some light? Would you just randomly move in with a guy you knew from school and a handful of conversations from parties?





Originally Posted by SwampWitch

She's also baiting you to see how much you want her. I'm guessing your indifference isn't helping her decide if she wants something more permanent with you or not. I know you told her you have feelings, but it sounds like she wants to see you prove it on a daily basis.
My indifference is due to the fact that she flat out refuses and then continues to give me mixed reactions. Mind you I have not done this in a few weeks, but whenever I attempted to get closer to her, she retracted. I would think this would be a clear indication of her intent.
 

ut0pia

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 25, 2008
Messages
5,120
Purraise
34
Originally Posted by ancientsanskrit

Can any female shed some light? Would you just randomly move in with a guy you knew from school and a handful of conversations from parties?
I don't think that's unusual....There is not much wrong with moving in with someone to split the rent.. Someone you know from school is even better because you know he's not a thug
...
 

carolina

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 17, 2008
Messages
14,759
Purraise
215
Location
Corinth, TX
Originally Posted by ancientsanskrit

My sentiments, exactly. I've never gotten to the bottom of it, but why would she move in with me? I've never had a girl so quickly just move in with me. Only situation was from a long-term relationship. It is a unique situation, and I feel she may just be using me for her own security feeling. Can any female shed some light? Would you just randomly move in with a guy you knew from school and a handful of conversations from parties?
She moved in with you as a roommate, that's all - IMO you are reading way too much in the "moving in together" part of it. That's not what happened - you both needed to split rent, utilities, and you had a room to spare, and she was looking for a place... voila. There is really nothing more to it...
From your post:
At the time she was looking for a place to live and I was looking for roommate to split my rent. At the time I indicated that I was dating, but not looking for a relationship per se.
Now, What you are going through IMO is very typical of a roommate platonic relationship, actually.... And if you have feelings for her I am with your male friends, move out and move on.
Here is what happens in this relationship: She won't be with you, but she is going to manipulate you just so you are not going to be with anyone else. Yep, she will play a game on your head. Nope, she doesn't want you. Not romantically, anyways... It is a weird dynamic that sometimes very good friends have...
Kind of.... I am not really sure I want to date you, but for the time being you are not dating anybody else.
Hard to explain, a woman thing.... doesn't happen a lot, but sometimes women are jealous of some of their friends and they do NOT want anybody to date them.
A friend of mine almost killed me when I wanted to date our mutual friend (and roommate) long time ago... When I confronted her why, and if she was in love with him, she said NO, but I WAS NOT ALLOWED TO DATE HIM!!! and THAT was THAT! And she would KILL me if I did so!
And believe me when I tell you, she was serious!
And she manipulated him that not even if I wanted...

Is that fair? No. Not at all...
IMO the only way you can be healthy and happy in this situation is to move out....

And... another thing: Just try your very very very very BEST to go back to the way things were before you told her your feelings. Because if you become clingy, or if you start tripping, or saying things, and she is not on the same place as you are, it is going to create a situation where it will become very hard to live together.
I know this is hard to hear, but as roommates, that is something to watch out for... now it is time for you to have some space, and to give her some more space.
 

snake_lady

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 9, 2008
Messages
7,218
Purraise
13
Location
ON./Canada
Originally Posted by ancientsanskrit

My sentiments, exactly. I've never gotten to the bottom of it, but why would she move in with me? I've never had a girl so quickly just move in with me. Only situation was from a long-term relationship. It is a unique situation, and I feel she may just be using me for her own security feeling. Can any female shed some light? Would you just randomly move in with a guy you knew from school and a handful of conversations from parties?
Yes I would, if he's a decent guy (which it sounds like you are) and I needed a place to stay.

She does remind me of a lot of my ex's all mixed in together....

- not willing to commit ( one way or another)
- seems to be jealous when you are chatting with other women (this one is HUGE to me.... about 6mos after my daughters father left me, I started dating... he knew this.... I feel in love with a man, and my ex then said that he wanted to come back into my life. Being the fool I was, and wanting to be a family for my daughter, I let him. He LEFT again, the NEXT day.... but had succeeded in doing what he wanted, wrecking my relationship at that time because he was jealous to see me happy).

Honestly, if it were me, I'd continue along the road of your one statement
I'm starting to let go, and move on. This rant is really due to an incidence tonight. I met a really interesting girl at Barnes and Nobles, and we decided to go for coffee and talk this evening. When heading out, I got "the inquisitive eye" from her. I kept noticing her glancing at me while trying to look occupied watching TV.
 

trouts mom

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 4, 2006
Messages
23,949
Purraise
16
Location
Snowy Santa Land
Ugh. Some women just lead guys on because they like the attention. I truly think that it is not done on purpose though.

I used to do this when I was in college..actually I led my now husband on terribly, but when he would show interest I would blow him off.
It wasn't until 8 years later that I realized we had something so strong and I messed it up.

So anyway, I have no advice because even for me women are hard to understand. Just hang in there...and move on. There are women out there who aren't so wishy washy.
 

crazyforinfo

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
May 26, 2006
Messages
6,773
Purraise
4
Location
Philly
She sounds lonely. She enjoys flirting with you b/c in her mind it won't go anyway. She misses that part of dating and feels safe with you. She isn't into you like you are into her though.
 

otto

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 7, 2008
Messages
9,837
Purraise
197
I think this woman is into head games and has an issue with controlling people. Potential abuser written all over her. She's said she's not into you, but continues to monitor your movements and interfere in your personal life.

My opinion is she's bad news and it is time you tell her to find other accommodations. Tell her the roommate thing is not working out and she has a month to find somewhere else, and then stick to it.

(PS I am a woman, but know what it's like to live with a sick game playing control freak. get her out NOW!)
 

swampwitch

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 30, 2006
Messages
7,753
Purraise
158
Location
Tall Trees & Cold Seas Vancouver Island
Originally Posted by ancientsanskrit

...Would you just randomly move in with a guy you knew from school and a handful of conversations from parties?
I've done that before, in college, always was a disaster and it took me a while to catch on not to do that. But I was always honest about my feelings towards them and my actions were in sync with my words.


Originally Posted by ancientsanskrit

My indifference is due to the fact that she flat out refuses and then continues to give me mixed reactions. Mind you I have not done this in a few weeks, but whenever I attempted to get closer to her, she retracted. I would think this would be a clear indication of her intent.
I didn't mean to imply that your indifference was not a good reaction; in fact I believe you are doing the exactly right thing by staying neutral and observing what she's doing and what messages she's sending you.

There are millions of reasons why she could be unsure about getting close to you; maybe she still has love for that past boyfriend, maybe this is how her father showed her love, maybe she's scared of losing your friendship... it could be anything. Personally, I think she's crazy, nuts, and maybe you want to invest hours of each day counseling her for years (you sound like you'd be great at it), but maybe you don't want that.

Originally Posted by otto

I think this woman is into head games and has an issue with controlling people. Potential abuser written all over her. She's said she's not into you, but continues to monitor your movements and interfere in your personal life.

My opinion is she's bad news and it is time you tell her to find other accommodations. Tell her the roommate thing is not working out and she has a month to find somewhere else, and then stick to it.

(PS I am a woman, but know what it's like to live with a sick game playing control freak. get her out NOW!)
Yeah, I agree with this as a very good possibility. Is she mean? Mean and crazy is a very bad combo. A decent woman with her head together at all would talk to you about what's going on. There would be no red flags where words and actions don't match.
 

carolina

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 17, 2008
Messages
14,759
Purraise
215
Location
Corinth, TX
I am going to be a bit of Devil's advocate here... I am sorry... But... There is Always TWO sides for each story... Let me explain before someone shoots me:
What you wrote is your interpretation to the way she is acting in this whole situation. And it is - for more than you try to distance yourself, you are inside of the situation, and what you write is highly biased towards your side, and against her.
Now, being a woman, I can tell you that is highly uncomfortable to be around someone who you care about on a friendship level, but know that this person has feelings for you. It is AWFUL.
You want to be there as a friend, but don't know how to act. If you ask where the the other person is going out to, or with who, JUST LIKE BEFORE this person opened up her feelings for you, is that crossing the line? Is that playing a game? Being Crazy? A "B" Word?
Then there is the other side - you ignore the person. Oh, then you REALLY are a "B" word.
This Girl, who no one knows has been called everything here... and she is probably none of it... She is probably just in a very darn uncomfortable situation. It is NOT easy to have someone liking you when you are not on the same page - especially on the same house, when there is no where to go to... and there is a friendship to try to preserve. IMO there is a high probability that this girl is being misunderstood.
 

natalie_ca

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 2, 2006
Messages
21,136
Purraise
223
Location
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
As a woman, my advice to you is to don't even bother trying to understand a woman! I'm a girl and I gave up trying to understand my gender decades ago! There really is no rhyme or reason behind many of the things that we do. Chalk it up to hormones. More advice.... join a monestary and become a monk and be happy!
 

emrldsky

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jun 27, 2006
Messages
2,335
Purraise
2
Location
Nuh uh...might give me away!
I honestly think a conversation needs to take place between you two. You live together, you don't want to leave her high-and-dry, and you care about her. Yet there's tension. Ya'll need to sit down and talk it out.

Explain to her that you must have misinterpreted her actions as affection beyond friendship and that you apologize if your interpretation caused conflict when you admitted your feelings. Explain that you understand that by admitting how you felt it put you both in an awkward situation: you, with feelings she doesn't share and her, not knowing what to do with your feelings.

Maybe just tell her that you don't want her to move out, but you don't want you both to feel uncomfortable with what has happened. Tell her that you're perfectly fine to remain being friends, but that because you've misinterpreted her actions in the past, boundaries must be set. You can figure out what you can and cannot put up with.

I've had guy friends in the past admit their feelings to me, and I've botched things up big time. As I got older, I got better at handling things, but because I didn't want to "deal with it" I didn't know what to do with their feelings once they admitted them. I think she just doesn't know what to do. A calm, mature, and controlled conversation could have saved friendships in the past.

And I'm going to avoid trying to figure out what's going on in her mind, because she could be posting to another forum somewhere saying that her roommate, a guy, admitted having feelings for her and she's really freaked out. *shrug*

You NEVER know what a person's thinking/feeling if you don't talk about it.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #15

ancientsanskrit

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2008
Messages
115
Purraise
18
Location
In TX, but will always be a Michigan-boy.
Originally Posted by carolinalima

I am going to be a bit of Devil's advocate here... I am sorry... But... There is Always TWO sides for each story... Let me explain before someone shoots me:
What you wrote is your interpretation to the way she is acting in this whole situation. And it is - for more than you try to distance yourself, you are inside of the situation, and what you write is highly biased towards your side, and against her.
I appreciate the viewpoints from everyone, but I believe you really struck a cord on this one. First and foremost, this girl is a sweet girl. She by no means deserves any of the names she has been associated with. I appreciate you pointing this out.

I tried to approach it as unbiased as possible, and there is much more information I could add which would diminish her image, but I chose not to add it.

You are absolutely right that in some form or fashion I am presenting a somewhat biased interpretation of it all.

---Sorry, it's too much of a headache to multi-quote, so I'm just placing quotation marks from your response:

"Now, being a woman, I can tell you that is highly uncomfortable to be around someone who you care about on a friendship level, but know that this person has feelings for you. It is AWFUL."

I understand this position. I think such a position transcends any gender, as I have had females approach me in terms of hooking up, yet I wanted to keep it strictly at a friendship level.


"You want to be there as a friend, but don't know how to act. If you ask where the the other person is going out to, or with who, JUST LIKE BEFORE this person opened up her feelings for you, is that crossing the line? Is that playing a game? Being Crazy? A "B" Word? "

I disagree with this one. This just doesn't make sense to me and it never will. If you had feelings for someone at more than a friendship level you would be curious about their personal life and there whereabouts at night. It's not like she asks me where I'm going during the day or where I'm going out to lunch in the afternoon. Sorry, I don't buy it.


" She is probably just in a very darn uncomfortable situation. It is NOT easy to have someone liking you when you are not on the same page - especially on the same house, when there is no where to go to..."

See that's just it. This girl is from Lubbock, TX. She has lived here all her life and her friends, family, etc are all here. I'm from Detroit, MI, and didn't know anyone in the state of TX when I relocated from MI last year. So, I don't really think that's the case.

To further add fuel to the fire, I got her riled up on something I can't really recall now, but she mentioned that the ex-bf she is now seeing has offered her to stay at his place for free. Like me, she is pretty cost-conscious as we're both in graduate school. Also mind you that I opened up to her a month ago, and she still continues to stay with me should that option of her ex-bf be true.

Just clarifying/justifying some points. Appreciate the feedback ladies.


I'll be honest, moving out has crossed my mind, and it actually was almost decided for me, as I had a job offer in Indiana. I think this only further complicated issues as she may have become defensive at the prospect of me moving back to the midwest. I just dunno.
 

calico2222

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 9, 2004
Messages
7,731
Purraise
41
Location
Over the river and through the woods...
Wow...I'll be honest. She sounds like me back in my 20's. At that point, I was "playing the field", and flexing my power...if that makes sense. I know I was a big tease and loved the attention. Maybe it was confidence issues. But, I had one guy that was my best friend that was always my "night in shining armour". He would save me when I got in over my head. I would get mad if he was talking to another woman, but would also get mad if he interrupted me talking with another guy. He finally had enough and moved away, and I moved away.

Guess what, 8 years later we were standing at the alter getting married.

Why do women play head games? I don't have a clue. I didn't think I was messing with his head, but I was. Right now you got to figure out what is best for you. If it's too stressful staying there, move out. Is the "L" word there? Or is it just attraction and caring?
 

ut0pia

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 25, 2008
Messages
5,120
Purraise
34
Originally Posted by calico2222

Wow...I'll be honest. She sounds like me back in my 20's. At that point, I was "playing the field", and flexing my power...if that makes sense. I know I was a big tease and loved the attention. Maybe it was confidence issues. But, I had one guy that was my best friend that was always my "night in shining armour". He would save me when I got in over my head. I would get mad if he was talking to another woman, but would also get mad if he interrupted me talking with another guy. He finally had enough and moved away, and I moved away.

Guess what, 8 years later we were standing at the alter getting married.

Why do women play head games? I don't have a clue. I didn't think I was messing with his head, but I was. Right now you got to figure out what is best for you. If it's too stressful staying there, move out. Is the "L" word there? Or is it just attraction and caring?
This is what I thought too....I do this stuff too sometimes, I generally make the conscious decision not to start relationships at this stage in my life while I'm in my 20s, and I have the same attitude a lot of times, just flirting but not taking it any further. However, if I'm really into someone, even though I've made that decision, once I fall for someone it's like emotions take over and I no longer think logically, I'm willing to do just about anything to have spend as much time as possible with the guy... Which is why what I'm thinking is that she isn't into him all that much, if she can just keep it platonic, because if she was she wouldn't be able to help herself lol...In other words, it doesn't sound tru luv/infatuation lol
 

carolina

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 17, 2008
Messages
14,759
Purraise
215
Location
Corinth, TX
Originally Posted by ancientsanskrit

I appreciate the viewpoints from everyone, but I believe you really struck a cord on this one. First and foremost, this girl is a sweet girl. She by no means deserves any of the names she has been associated with. I appreciate you pointing this out.

I tried to approach it as unbiased as possible, and there is much more information I could add which would diminish her image, but I chose not to add it.

You are absolutely right that in some form or fashion I am presenting a somewhat biased interpretation of it all.

---Sorry, it's too much of a headache to multi-quote, so I'm just placing quotation marks from your response:

"Now, being a woman, I can tell you that is highly uncomfortable to be around someone who you care about on a friendship level, but know that this person has feelings for you. It is AWFUL."

I understand this position. I think such a position transcends any gender, as I have had females approach me in terms of hooking up, yet I wanted to keep it strictly at a friendship level.


"You want to be there as a friend, but don't know how to act. If you ask where the the other person is going out to, or with who, JUST LIKE BEFORE this person opened up her feelings for you, is that crossing the line? Is that playing a game? Being Crazy? A "B" Word? "

I disagree with this one. This just doesn't make sense to me and it never will. If you had feelings for someone at more than a friendship level you would be curious about their personal life and there whereabouts at night. It's not like she asks me where I'm going during the day or where I'm going out to lunch in the afternoon. Sorry, I don't buy it. I am sorry... This is my opinion, and IMO you are reading too much into it... yes we do ask in casual conversations where are you going tonight EVEN if we don't have feelings for you. I am 35 and I had plenty of roommates - I asked this question plenty of times... and to this day I ask my friends - be them single, married, divorced, widowed... The point being - It does NOT IMPLY I want something with them.


" She is probably just in a very darn uncomfortable situation. It is NOT easy to have someone liking you when you are not on the same page - especially on the same house, when there is no where to go to..."

See that's just it. This girl is from Lubbock, TX. She has lived here all her life and her friends, family, etc are all here. I'm from Detroit, MI, and didn't know anyone in the state of TX when I relocated from MI last year. So, I don't really think that's the case. This has nothing to do with it - I am talking about living in the same house - I am not saying the same city.... You are the inside her personal space... and on these circumstances it can make things uncomfortable.

To further add fuel to the fire, I got her riled up on something I can't really recall now, but she mentioned that the ex-bf she is now seeing has offered her to stay at his place for free. Like me, she is pretty cost-conscious as we're both in graduate school. Also mind you that I opened up to her a month ago, and she still continues to stay with me should that option of her ex-bf be true. I totally understand her. She is with you as your roommate, while if she moved in with him, it would mean a commitment - and as you say, he is her EX-boyfriend...

Just clarifying/justifying some points. Appreciate the feedback ladies.


I'll be honest, moving out has crossed my mind, and it actually was almost decided for me, as I had a job offer in Indiana. I think this only further complicated issues as she may have become defensive at the prospect of me moving back to the midwest. I just dunno.
I know this is not what you want to hear.... It is clear now to me that you want to hear that this girl is in love with you, but she doesn't know and/or she is playing games...
IMHO, I am SO sorry to say, She is NOT in to you. She is your friend, she has made it clear, and you are reading way too much into it.
The more you write about it, the more clear it becomes to me...
IMO this girl is just a normal girl trying to do her thing, live her life - unfortunately you took a risk that sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.... And when you live together it tends to get very complicated... There is not mystery to what you are going through, to sum it up in one paragraph:

Boy lives with girl. Boy likes girl, but girl is not into boy. Girl is uncomfortable around boy. Boy trips out. Girl gets more uncomfortable. Boy trips out more. Girl gets even more uncomfortable. Boy trips out even more. Girl gets out of control. Boy gets out of control.

Look, It is not easy what you are going through, but to try to understand is just going to hurt you...

IMHO there is just nothing to understand... She wants to be your friend and that's that... You guys live together, and if you want to be healthy and happy you will need to accept this... Otherwise you will need to just move out...
That's just how it is...

 

calico2222

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 9, 2004
Messages
7,731
Purraise
41
Location
Over the river and through the woods...
Originally Posted by carolinalima

I know this is not what you want to hear.... It is clear now to me that you want to hear that this girl is in love with you, but she doesn't know and/or she is playing games...
IMHO, I am SO sorry to say, She is NOT in to you. She is your friend, she has made it clear, and you are reading way too much into it.
The more you write about it, the more clear it becomes to me...
IMO this girl is just a normal girl trying to do her thing, live her life - unfortunately you took a risk that sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.... And when you live together it tends to get very complicated... There is not mystery to what you are going through, to sum it up in one paragraph:

Boy lives with girl. Boy likes girl, but girl is not into boy. Girl is uncomfortable around boy. Boy trips out. Girl gets more uncomfortable. Boy trips out more. Girl gets even more uncomfortable. Boy trips out even more. Girl gets out of control. Boy gets out of control.

Look, It is not easy what you are going through, but to try to understand is just going to hurt you...

IMHO there is just nothing to understand... She wants to be your friend and that's that... You guys live together, and if you want to be healthy and happy you will need to accept this... Otherwise you will need to just move out...
That's just how it is...

I see it differently. She IS giving out mixed signals IMO. The whole "I don't play games" thing when he's talking to another girl says that she IS playing games. I think she is scared and really needs to grow up.

Best thing for you is to either move out, or tell her to move out. Obviously, it isn't working and causing you more stress. I'm not saying she is in love with you or vise versa...but with some space maybe you can get back to the friendship you had before and see what happens from there.
 
Top