Evangers is a good company.
At the time of the recall they were one of the few grain free and non-recall factory foods (at least as I was informed at the time).
Anyways their cat foods are ok, but their consistency went downhill last year and they added grain.
The food just got pasty, and my cat started rejecting it wholesale.
If you want to do a "Whole meat diet" check out these brands:http://www.naturesvariety.com/instinct_cat_can
(chicken and rabbit are great, and my kitties favorite)http://www.evopet.com/products/default.asp?id=1662
There is also Wellness Core which is so new noone I know has tried it yet.
If you never fed a cat a wet only diet, better hope you have a dishwasher! Its a PITA with 2 dirty dishes a day.
I recommend getting a large set of Cornelle bowls for you and your cat to share
Besides health benefits, wet makes it POSSIBLE to control calories (one can is usually a cats daily intake) and aides in behaviour enhancement with food association.