I burned my finger on a poptart. Yes I pulled out of the toaster before it cooled.
OMG! I did that one day and it burned my thumb so badly it bubbled up and blistered! I wanted to cry. The frosting actually carmelized on my thumb and I stupidly put it in my mouth and ripped the frosting off then put it under cold water for like 20 minutes and it still hurt for days! I have pictures in my phone of what it looked like. It was gross!
It was the frosting. it stuck to my finger. I prefer toaster strudle, but I only had poptarts. of course my 5 year old had to be there. "Mom you always tell me to wait"
That's what happened to me! I looked away because the cats were raising a ruckus and I was grabbing for the poptart at the same time, and my thumb went into the frosting and WOW holy croppies!!!!! my finger was on fire!!!