Problem with picky eater, questions about canned food

apollotrigger

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
May 15, 2007
Messages
12
Purraise
0
Location
Memphis, TN
I'm having a food problem with my girls. (For the record and just because I love sharing: 7 year old Milly, black and white tabby ; 3 year old Lady, orange and white tabby ; 2 year old Angel, gray tabby ; Mia, almost year old gray and tan, part maine coon ; and the baby, Kisa, 5 month old black and white tabby) I have a couple of picky eats.

I have been feeding them Purina One Naturals for the past year or so. They all loved it, and things were great. When we got the new kitten 3 months ago we bought some Purina Kitten Chow for her, which the others were crazy about. I'd mix it in with their food just so they'd leave poor Kisa's food alone!

Well about 3 weeks ago every single store in my area stopped carrying the Purina One Naturals. I fed the girls on Kitten Chow for a few weeks while I tried to hunt down their normal food, but no luck. About a week ago Lady started dropping weight. I bought a bag of IAMs mutli-cat household, since I've always heard amazing things about IAMs. That was 4 days ago. Her weight kept dropping. I was starting to get frantic, and I begged my mother to come over and bring some can food to see if maybe she'd eat that.

Sure enough, she's happily chowing down on the canned food and getting back up to a good weight. We checked her teeth throughly and can see nothing wrong, and I've been keeping up with a good teeth brushing schedule for all of them, so all I can think is she's just being picky about what she eats.

My mother has always told me that too much canned food isn't good for an animal. Her cats only get canned food once a month or so. That's how I've been doing it with my cats. Am I misguided here? I have so many questions I'm just going to number them!

1. Is canned food safe for cats to eat all the time?
2. If so, can someone suggest a good, healthy food for them?
3. If not, can someone suggest a good, healthy food that they've had luck with picky eaters on?
4. How often do you feed your cats canned food?

Is canned food even the right terminology? So much of it doesn't come in cans lol. Well, thank you in advance!
 

iluvdevons

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
May 31, 2007
Messages
757
Purraise
2
Location
Lincoln, NE
Originally Posted by Apollotrigger

My mother has always told me that too much canned food isn't good for an animal. Her cats only get canned food once a month or so. That's how I've been doing it with my cats. Am I misguided here? I have so many questions I'm just going to number them!

1. Is canned food safe for cats to eat all the time?
2. If so, can someone suggest a good, healthy food for them?
3. If not, can someone suggest a good, healthy food that they've had luck with picky eaters on?
4. How often do you feed your cats canned food?

Is canned food even the right terminology? So much of it doesn't come in cans lol. Well, thank you in advance!
Hi, I know that others on this site can give you more info on specific brands that might work for your kitties, but the idea that wet food is bad for kitties is untrue. Many people feed their cats an all wet diet. With Ares and Hypnos, I feed them wet food almost 100% of the time. (I leave small amounts of dry food out overnight or when we are gone for periods of time.) There are a number of benefits to a wet diet. As long as you brush your kitties' teeth, I see no reason to hold back on the wet food
 
G

ghostuser

Guest
My cat eats almost exclusively wet food.. I leave dry out for the rare occasion he'll take a bite, and for my sister's cat. They get Nutro Natural Choice (regular) for their dry, and for wet they mostly get Nutro Max cans, with some Iams, Wellness, and Pro Plan cans for variety (and because that's what Chase will eat).

As for suggesting foods.. how much can you spend, and where can you shop? That makes a big difference in what people will suggest. If you're looking at grocery store foods, this thread lists some decent ones you can get, though you'll find better choices at a pet store.
 

sharky

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
27,231
Purraise
38
1. Is canned food safe for cats to eat all the time?

YES YES and YES
2. If so, can someone suggest a good, healthy food for them?
the grocery link has IMHO the best at the grocery stores .... If you want premiums I will happily list
3. If not, can someone suggest a good, healthy food that they've had luck with picky eaters on?
picky eaters often eat max cat by nutro .... chicken soup also seems to work
4. How often do you feed your cats canned food?
I aim for 50 wet 50 dry ... but currently I have lovely girl who catches her canned and loves dry
 
Top