I am with you Christy, it was nice to see Lionel there. I thought he was a great guest judge. The best so far. He seemed like a real fan of the show.
I loved the song that Clay sang, it brings back such memories, and I was totally on the same track as Ryan Seacrest. Everytime I hear that song I think of Family Ties. I can't help it. Clay did wonderfully. He is still my favorite, but Reuben is creeping in there!
Reuben, Josh, Ricky and Kim L. did really well too. I wish there were more upbeat songs though, seemed it was all about the ballad last night. Hopefully that won't be an upcoming theme.
Carmen and Kim C. were just terrble. Yuck. Now, I like Carmen in general, but I just thought it was a terrible selection for her and I was right with Simon on that. Kim C. seemed like she was trying to step outside her box, and my god she should stay in the box. Get back in the box woman!
Trenyce, I mean the girl has talent right? Then why is it every time she goes for the high notes I feel like my ears are going to bleed? Was it just me? Probably.
My pick to go: Carmen
Personally I would want Kim C. to go, but since they have that carry over thing happening from last week, I am guessing Carmen.
Ok, I think that is it.