Top three picks on wet food... your opinions please

Hi everyone!

Okay, I've boiled it down to three brands of canned food. Eagle Pack, Wellness and Go! Natural. Jake likes all three but I'd be interested in getting your feedback as to which one is the better brand.

I know it depends on the cat and what works best for them but I'm leary of what my pet food store is telling me because I would suspect that they get some sort of incentive from the companies to sell their products.

That's why I would like to draw on the experience of the folks here. I just want to give him the best. He's a 12 (almost 13) year old Abyssinian with no health problems (short of taking a potassium suppliment).

Thanks for anything opinions you have to offer. All these choices are making me go loopy!

Wellness in the grain free is my first choice

then Go natural ( thou up close I have only seen the dog

Eagle pack is good but of these three is the last pic

I like Wellness & Eagle Pack, but only because my Damita, who has allergies/tummy issues does well on both.

We feed Wellness, Natural Balance and PetGuard. So I'd go with Wellness, too.

Why do you want to choose one brand? Why not use all three in rotation? There's no reason to stick with one brand; in fact, it's better if you don't. I use Eagle Pack and Wellness along with Prairie, California Natural, Merrick's, Innova, Natural Balance, and (!) Fancy Feast.

The only reason I can see for avoiding any brand is if your cat either doesn't like it or has some health issue with it.

I'm with Tim. Do you need to feed only one brand? They're all good foods. If your kitty likes all three, why not feed all three?

I'm with Tim & Jen!

I should put I rotate about 8 brands

Originally Posted by coaster

Why do you want to choose one brand? Why not use all three in rotation? There's no reason to stick with one brand; in fact, it's better if you don't. I use Eagle Pack and Wellness along with Prairie, California Natural, Merrick's, Innova, Natural Balance, and (!) Fancy Feast.

The only reason I can see for avoiding any brand is if your cat either doesn't like it or has some health issue with it.

Click to expand...

IMHO, it's better to rotate. Not only will you (hopefully) keep them from getting tired of a particular variety, but should another contamination scare occur, you won't be feeding them the same thing day after day.

I rotate several brands and I try not to give the favorites too often.

Originally Posted by JellyBella

IMHO, it's better to rotate. Not only will you (hopefully) keep them from getting tired of a particular variety, but should another contamination scare occur, you won't be feeding them the same thing day after day.

I rotate several brands and I try not to give the favorites too often.

Click to expand...

Very good point!