I told her that she couldn't just have 1 kitten (you can never have just 1- like the potato chips! Lol!) and she needed to keep 1 of the others that someone had dumped off.
I suppose I should give the background of kitten #1, aka Princess Jenny (weird name, but whatever, she has a 2 year old and a 4 year old). Jamie, my sister, has animals dropped at her house all the time. She had a dog dropped off this year and numerous cats/kittens. Last time, she had 3 kittens dropped off. They kept Princess Jenny and gave away her sibling because my BIL said only 1 cat. The other kitten disappeared. Jamie said they saw a coyote around so I can only think of 1 place the poor kitten could have gone (the kitten got outside and they couldn't find her). That kitten looked to be about 3-4 months old and the other 2 seemed to be out of the same litter, about 8 weeks. So, long story short, my sister decided that I was right and they needed another kitten. She has been scouring Petfinder and talking to the pounds around here so, hopefully, she will find 1 that fits with the family!
Edited to add: she's looking for a cat like my Pepper because she loves him, but she's having some trouble finding a cat that is enough like him. I tried to tell her that there is only 1 Pepper,but she's convinced she can find another. Silly sister!!