Need some suggestions...going to the pet store

Finally I have the time to make the drive to the pet store (an hour away). And I need some suggestions. For dry I already know I will get either T.O. or Orijen (leaning more towards Orijen from what I have read here). But for wet I am still unsure what to get. Ping loves the Instinctive Choice but I am not afford the 30 some dollars (thats with shipping) to get that. So is there something equvilate (sp?) to that. I have tried all the Merrick canned foods and all of them bombed here. I think that may have been a texture thing more than anything. I tried canned Felidea and that bombed. So some suggestions of things to try.