Quote:
Originally Posted by Bonnie1965 
Okay, this is a touchy topic for me and not at all sure I should respond.
First, I notice a lot of "theys" and "thems" when referring to illegal immigrants. I think this would be a much more productive discussion if some of those immigrants were here to speak. If they are members, they will not speak up, out of fear I am sure. I also wonder how many people of color take part in these IMO discussions that seem to center around the race issue?.
|
i am sorry , but i dont care what the illegals have to say. some my say that is racist, but its not, i dont care what any non american who came to america has to say about sneaking in, and thinking they have the right to be here cause they where able to break the law,,, the law being the keyword.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bonnie1965 
I may be way off base, if I am just let me know, but I find that the good ol' legal, white bread, apple pie Americans tend to forget that not so long ago (truly is was not THAT long ago in the scheme of things), our people were the illegals. No, there were no ritzy politicians arguing over whether or not they could stay. My people barged in, took what they wanted, raped, killed, mutilated and then LEGALLY embarked upon an extermination campaign. My people took what they wanted no matter what. Were they all bad people? No, but they were brainwashed and uneducated. Does that excuse their behavior? No. Does it excuse the blindness of their descendents? No. My people could have made concessions and worked with the people who were here but they chose to exercise their bullcrud manifest destiny instead.?.
|
and that is proof of what can happen when a goverment does not control its borders and allows uncrontled immigrantion. maybe you have not seen the radical side of illeglas who say they are here to chase us, back out of America? I know of no one who says what took place to the indians was a good thing.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bonnie1965 
My people drew the lines that separated an entire continent. They told the current residents, those who had somehow managed to survive, what side of that line they could be on. Families, culture, lifeways - didn't matter. My people wanted it done this way and that is the way it was done.
In this time, there were several countries vying for the land. They managed to intermarry or otherwise create mixed children. Yet still, we create boundaries and borders even for those that carry our precious European blood.
There was a world war that again needed a target. So people who resembled a certain "race" were gathered into detention camps. Again, a them and us schema..?.
|
Nation buliding is never a pretty thing and even less so back then. I nor you are gulity of any of those things, We did not drive the indians into camps,
nor do we force them them to stay there now. do i feel bad for what happen to them, yes of course i do, But i feel no gulit, I had nothing to do with it.
what happends to the japanese americans was also wrong, we know that.
do we now, lock up any arab american we see? No, we dont. so i would say that was one lesson that was learned.
When you invade another country with out being asked in, it is a us vs them thing. No on asked on invited people to come sneaking in.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bonnie1965 
I mention this because as much as we believe we have evolved, we have not come so far. I was born the week of the March on Selma - March 1965. It wasn't that long ago. Some things have changed but the fact that the kkk (lower case is purposeful) still has the power to instill fear shows how little we have progressed.
My father was around until I was 9 and he raised us to hate anyone different. If the klan would have had him, he would have gone. Ever see those photos of people at a rally without the hoods? It frightens me how they resemble my relatives.
So, here we sit complaining about "illegal" immigrants. What if we didn't spend 500 billion dollars on a war? Would that give us more money that the terrible illegals have cheated us out of? What were we focusing on before the illegals became an issue? Why do we, as a people, allow an organization such as the kkk (and the offshoots) to have power?
I have people at work who complain about dealing with customers who don't "speak the language". I ask them what language they would rather those people speak. Invariably, I get something like "They should speak American!" Then I ask if they themselves speak American. They always look at me funny and ask what I mean. I inquire if they speak Lakota, Umatilla, Apache, Yacolt, Ojibwa, Klallam, Salish dialect or some other. Those are examples of American languages. English is British and it is a lovely language. I am just sick and tired of Joe Blow (or Jo) America assuming his/her way is the only way.
In many areas of the continent, Spanish was spoken before Engish and is spoken still. I suppose these people just need to stay where we say they should stay and only speak their language there. Heaven forbid good ol’ American white woman me should have to make allowances for another culture. I come from people who simply do not do that. Kill them, kick them out, yes. Cooperate, no.
|
I was also raised with a father that called every race by any name other then what they are There is no need to repeat them as we all know the names.
how other languages are cool, when i was hong kong, bangkok, indo, i used or made the effort to learn to speak there language, every major wave of people coming to america faced racism , be there irish, italin,chinese,etc,
those groups did spend the time to learn english, many of the people coming in now make no effort to learn the language of the land. The US constitution was written in english that makes it the language of the land.
Spending the money on the war makes no difference, The goverment is not doing what is main job is supposed to be, TO PROTECT THE BORDERS OF THIS COUNTRY, that is supposed to be there main job.
I do not see anyone here saying
kill them i see people saying that controls need to be in place to stop it. but your right, i want the illegals out,
they are breaking the law,
why do people see this as a racist issue? its not, i dont care if they come europe, asia, mexcia or the moon, COME in legal and there is no problem..
Bonnie i hope you dont think i am flaming you, cause i am not, i am just posting my views on what you said, or how i saw it.
