LOST Fans?

jenny82

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Apr 19, 2006
Messages
5,773
Purraise
114
Location
Maryland
Originally Posted by Crazyforinfo

When Jack & Juliet were on the beach with Kate and Jack said "Not Yet" that's when I started thinking that Juliet told Jack about Ben's plan & that someone else will be involved.
Ohh yeah I was wondering what that was all about!
 

catsarebetter

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 13, 2007
Messages
2,373
Purraise
2
Location
N. VA
Yeah, not sure what the "not yet" thing is about, but I don't think the parachute person is an other. A.) Juliette would know her if she were an other and sent to spy... b.) Don't forget that the helicopter was in Desmond's vision, even if they didn't see it irl (boy, that's subjective, isn't it?)....everything else in Desmond's vision was true so it stands to reason that all of it would be true.

I don't think it's too much of a stretch for the others to have caused the plane crash, for their own benefit.. (children stealing, back surgeon on the plane...people that are useful to them...) and then to stage the other plane/wreck so that people wouldn't be looking for the survivors. I mean.. with their "know-all" it's hard to imagine that they can't pull that off.
 

reesespbc

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
2,411
Purraise
1
Location
Baldwinville, MA
Originally Posted by Crazyforinfo

When Jack & Juliet were on the beach with Kate and Jack said "Not Yet" that's when I started thinking that Juliet told Jack about Ben's plan & that someone else will be involved.
I think Juliet and Jack know about the woman, and it's not what everyone who found her thinks it may be.
 

silentnate

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
1,592
Purraise
11
Location
London DHARMA HQ.
Originally Posted by Crazyforinfo

I think the lady is an Other & she lied about about finding the plane and dead bodies. I think she is there to help take the pregnant ladies like Ben said. Do you really think Ben trusts Julia to spy on her own? I also think they mentioned hell so we can all dismiss that theory.
Sorry but no- Locke's father also confirmed that the wreckage of the plane was found


Wasn't that their first episode without 'flashbacks' aside from a season finale?


A friend at work has already ruined the season finale for me
 

silentnate

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
1,592
Purraise
11
Location
London DHARMA HQ.
Originally Posted by ReesesPBC

I think Juliet and Jack know about the woman, and it's not what everyone who found her thinks it may be.
I reckon Juliet and Jack are plotting to stop the Others kidnapping Sun but thats just a guess at the moment
 

twstychik

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Messages
5,720
Purraise
4
Location
Northern IN
Originally Posted by ReesesPBC

Nothing is too elaborate for this show


I really hope they don't do the Hell/Purgatory angle. I think even if the creators didn't mention it, it would still be kind of a let down because that's what everyone has always thought the answer was. It's kind of like an obvious one.
Wow... I must be dense then cuz that option never occured to me till Locke's dad said it.
Originally Posted by Crazyforinfo

When Jack & Juliet were on the beach with Kate and Jack said "Not Yet" that's when I started thinking that Juliet told Jack about Ben's plan & that someone else will be involved.
I wondered about that. It was in that moment that I started really not liking Jack. I was on the fence till then.
Originally Posted by silentNate

I reckon Juliet and Jack are plotting to stop the Others kidnapping Sun but thats just a guess at the moment
That would be nice. I'm afraid that Jack may be the "help" that Juliet has recruited... all because Kate broke his heart.
 

twstychik

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Messages
5,720
Purraise
4
Location
Northern IN
Originally Posted by huggles

wow I gotta be careful not to read this thread as I dont want to spoil it for myself
That's a definate danger. I'm not usually up late enough so I tape them and watch the next day. I NEVER come here before I've watched it. One of my good friends is watching the old episodes to get caught up. I have to be careful what I say to her. I can't wait till she's caught up and we can dish about it.
 

catsarebetter

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 13, 2007
Messages
2,373
Purraise
2
Location
N. VA
Well, let's see... what are the theories so far?

As far as Jack is concerned.. they're just stranded on the island.. I don't recall anything with him being out of order.

Hurley's "theory" is they're all in the mental institution or at least he is and he's imagining all of them while he's in the hospital, and the numbers are bad luck (not much on that lately either).

Desmond's is that he's replaying this portion of his life over and over again, but they're all stranded on this island.. but did we ever establish if he was sent there by Dharma or if he just sort of stumbled onto the hatch after he wrecked?

Kate, Charlie and Sawyer just seem to be crashed and surviving.. no real storyline as to "why" they were sent there.

Claire (wait, I might be confusing her name with a character from Heroes..), the little blonde cute one that is dating Charlie and had the baby..she was in theory set up to get on that plane so that the baby wasn't given away.. remember the fortune teller prophesizing that the baby would be evil or evil would happen if it was given away? So, she was apparently destined to get on that plane to crash..at least it seemed that way to me.

Nothing really, with Sayid, or with Locke, in the way of some greater plan..that I can think of.

On another note, Jack is one of those characters who is cocky, but really is just a self-righteous holier than thou type.. (my sister and I disagree heartily on this.. she loves Jack, and hates Sawyer... I'm on the flip side of that) whereas Sawyer is cocky, and a snot, but at least he's not pretending to be a do gooder. His cockiness and attitude are straightforward.. you know what type of person he is from the get go.

I'm still debating on Juliette. I can't really decide on Locke either. I think Locke is very self-serving.. which I guess they all are to some degree.
 

huggles

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 3, 2003
Messages
9,620
Purraise
4
Location
Melbourne, Australia
Originally Posted by twstychik

That's a definate danger. I'm not usually up late enough so I tape them and watch the next day. I NEVER come here before I've watched it. One of my good friends is watching the old episodes to get caught up. I have to be careful what I say to her. I can't wait till she's caught up and we can dish about it.
I usually just come in after our weekly show, post what episode we are up to and then leave... I really dont try and read any of the threads tempting as it is.
 

twstychik

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Messages
5,720
Purraise
4
Location
Northern IN
Originally Posted by CatsAreBetter

Claire (wait, I might be confusing her name with a character from Heroes..), the little blonde cute one that is dating Charlie and had the baby
You've got the right name. But it's nice to know I'm not the only one who gets my Heros and Lost people confused! LOL

Originally Posted by huggles

I usually just come in after our weekly show, post what episode we are up to and then leave... I really dont try and read any of the threads tempting as it is.
My friend knows that if she asks I'll tell. For the most part she doesn't want to know what happens but she did ask about claire and her pregnancy. She had to know if the baby turned out ok.
 

katiemae1277

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Nov 28, 2005
Messages
20,445
Purraise
17
Location
NE OH
okay, I watched this week's episode last night, its on too late for me


I knew as soon as Locke came to get Sawyer that Locke's father was the one that conned Sawyer's family, to me, that was a little too predictable


I cannot believe that Kate went and told Jack about the girl, she's just trying to get back in his good graces. Sayid definitely suspected that the girl was an Other. also, on Kate, since she's sleeping with Sawyer, I bet she ends up pregnant at some point.

I hope Sawyer gets back in time to stop the kidnapping of Sun


I can't figure out the plane being found with everyone on it either
but then the Others have been proven to be capable of a lot of things... like how did they get the files on everyone? and them being SO detailed??

I hope Juliet gets caught too, I do not like her at all
and I'm pretty peeved at Jack too for siding with her, all I can think of he has a plan

I can't wait for the rest of the episodes!! Finally, Lost is back on track
 

reesespbc

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
2,411
Purraise
1
Location
Baldwinville, MA
Originally Posted by silentNate

Sorry but no- Locke's father also confirmed that the wreckage of the plane was found


Wasn't that their first episode without 'flashbacks' aside from a season finale?


A friend at work has already ruined the season finale for me
How did he ruin the finale? It hasn't happened yet.
 

twstychik

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Messages
5,720
Purraise
4
Location
Northern IN
Originally Posted by ReesesPBC

How did he ruin the finale? It hasn't happened yet.
I was wondering that myself... but I was afraid to ask cuz I wanna be surprised!
 

hopehacker

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 6, 2003
Messages
8,147
Purraise
4
Location
Los Angeles,CA
I can't figure out if Locke is Evil, or just plain crazy. I'm not sure if I like him or not.

I think they're all on the Island or where ever it is, because of sins or wrong doings they have done in the past. The only person I can see that seems to have done nothing evil is Hurley. As time goes by, we are all seeing how all of them are interconnected in their previous lives before the Island.

I think Locke is a weisel for not killing his own father, however I do see how it might help Sawyer to get rid of his demons for him to have done it, instead.

Does anyone think that maybe the Dharma Initiative has them all in some sort of experiment, and maybe they're controlling all of what is happening to them. Obviously, someone or something picked these particular people to be on the same plane at the same time, and it's obvious to me, that the plane was forcibly crashed, just so these people would all be there together.

I'm up in the air, regarding Juliette. It's obvious she's a mole for The Others, but it's also obvious to me, that's she's NOT ONE OF THE OTHERS. I am curious as to what the secret is that she and Jack share.
 

twstychik

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Messages
5,720
Purraise
4
Location
Northern IN
I'm not so sure Hurley is innocent. Sure, he didn't do anything obviously wrong but wasn't he warned about the numbers before he used them to win the lotto?
 

reesespbc

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
2,411
Purraise
1
Location
Baldwinville, MA
Originally Posted by HopeHacker

I can't figure out if Locke is Evil, or just plain crazy. I'm not sure if I like him or not.

I think they're all on the Island or where ever it is, because of sins or wrong doings they have done in the past. The only person I can see that seems to have done nothing evil is Hurley. As time goes by, we are all seeing how all of them are interconnected in their previous lives before the Island.

I think Locke is a weisel for not killing his own father, however I do see how it might help Sawyer to get rid of his demons for him to have done it, instead.

Does anyone think that maybe the Dharma Initiative has them all in some sort of experiment, and maybe they're controlling all of what is happening to them. Obviously, someone or something picked these particular people to be on the same plane at the same time, and it's obvious to me, that the plane was forcibly crashed, just so these people would all be there together.

I'm up in the air, regarding Juliette. It's obvious she's a mole for The Others, but it's also obvious to me, that's she's NOT ONE OF THE OTHERS. I am curious as to what the secret is that she and Jack share.
Well because Hurley hasn't done anything wrong (not that we know anyway), that may rule out the whole "sins done wrong" angle. We also also have to take into consideration that the Others were brought to the island, and Ben was born there. So why would some people be able to go there freely while those in the plane crash are there for sins or some other divine reason?

Personally, I like Locke. My wife hates him
He's always interested me because at first, he was this strong, wordly it seemed, almost Zen type of guy. Then it turned into that he was a man who had just lost his way, and now it seems like he's alittle of A & B. He's mysterious I think. Plus I'm just jealous I can't pull off the bald look
 

deelovely79

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
Mar 7, 2007
Messages
70
Purraise
0
I have a different take on the whole others found plane thing. So Dharma recruits "The Others" to run their research, subjects start dying.

Some how Dharma starts doing research to find new subjects and decides to get mostly criminal,troubled types who wouldn't be missed Sawyer, Kate, Sun & Jin, Anna, Echo, Sayed, Charlie and those two theives that got themselves buried.

They also wanted some people with illnesses to study the healing properties of the island Lock, the other survivor w/ Cancer, Libby, Hurley.

And there were a few children with special "qualities" that they had been monitoring from afar and decided this would be a good time to bring them to island Walt, Claire's unborn child.

They also decide to get another doctor since Juliet isn't as good as they had hoped and Ben's starting to distrust her - Jack.
(I still haven't figured out how Boone and his sister get into all this, maybe there was an error and then ended up booked on that flight).

They are all driven through circumstances to board the plane. When the planed is overhead the computer in the hatch goes off cuz the button wasn't pushed (I thought this happend with Desmond) and the plane crashes due to the disruption in the landing equipment.

Dharma gets another plane with cadavers ready and dumps it in the ocean and pays off inspectors to say that was the Oceanic flight. I believe its at this point when the Others start interacting with the Lost ones Ben gets caught etc since the search for them is over.

Penelope did send a search crew out (this was a clip way back sometime in the first two seasons before we knew who she was) now if the girl who Desmond and crew found is the same person who ejected from the plane remains to be seen (the Others probably saw the plane go down and possibly had already gotten the pilot and replaced him/her with the girl and let that one guy hang around to make it look good).

My thoughts, Walt and Micheal are dead (the were killed after they were "let go"). No one is getting off the island, no matter how many promises/deals that Ben makes. I believe he has orders to carry out certain experiments and no one will leave until the Dharma initiative has completed it's work (and probably not after that either). Lock right now is being recruited by Ben for an experiment but he has no idea because 1) Ben is the king of mind games and 2) He's deluded himself into thinking he has a spiritual connection with the island.
 

reesespbc

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
2,411
Purraise
1
Location
Baldwinville, MA
Originally Posted by DeeLovely79

I have a different take on the whole others found plane thing. So Dharma recruits "The Others" to run their research, subjects start dying.

Some how Dharma starts doing research to find new subjects and decides to get mostly criminal,troubled types who wouldn't be missed Sawyer, Kate, Sun & Jin, Anna, Echo, Sayed, Charlie and those two theives that got themselves buried.

They also wanted some people with illnesses to study the healing properties of the island Lock, the other survivor w/ Cancer, Libby, Hurley.

And there were a few children with special "qualities" that they had been monitoring from afar and decided this would be a good time to bring them to island Walt, Claire's unborn child.

They also decide to get another doctor since Juliet isn't as good as they had hoped and Ben's starting to distrust her - Jack.
(I still haven't figured out how Boone and his sister get into all this, maybe there was an error and then ended up booked on that flight).

They are all driven through circumstances to board the plane. When the planed is overhead the computer in the hatch goes off cuz the button wasn't pushed (I thought this happend with Desmond) and the plane crashes due to the disruption in the landing equipment.

Dharma gets another plane with cadavers ready and dumps it in the ocean and pays off inspectors to say that was the Oceanic flight. I believe its at this point when the Others start interacting with the Lost ones Ben gets caught etc since the search for them is over.

Penelope did send a search crew out (this was a clip way back sometime in the first two seasons before we knew who she was) now if the girl who Desmond and crew found is the same person who ejected from the plane remains to be seen (the Others probably saw the plane go down and possibly had already gotten the pilot and replaced him/her with the girl and let that one guy hang around to make it look good).

My thoughts, Walt and Micheal are dead (the were killed after they were "let go"). No one is getting off the island, no matter how many promises/deals that Ben makes. I believe he has orders to carry out certain experiments and no one will leave until the Dharma initiative has completed it's work (and probably not after that either). Lock right now is being recruited by Ben for an experiment but he has no idea because 1) Ben is the king of mind games and 2) He's deluded himself into thinking he has a spiritual connection with the island.
Wow...

You're good
This is by far the best "theory" explaination I've read yet. I have to show my wife this one.
 
Top