Old Cat .. New Cat?

bonnie1965

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Messages
3,973
Purraise
3
Location
Portland, Oregon
Hi

I have seen threads similar to this but not quite what I need to ask.

Sebastian and I live in a small studio apartment (around 300 sq ft). It isn't ideal but it is the best I can do for now.
Before we moved to this place a year ago, Sebastian was and indoor/outdoor guy. He loved going outside a few times a day to listen to the squirrels yell at him and pretend he could catch birds. At that time, we also lived with a siamese mix female cat a bit older than him. She didn't like him, he liked to play with her but since she hated him, it was tough to do.

However, he did have a girlfriend in the outside world. He was so gentle and loving with her and chased any other cats away who even thought about coming near our patio.
Yes, he has been fixed since he adopted me about 9 years ago (he is somewhere around 10 yrs old). The female he loved was also fixed.

Now, I am afraid he is lonely. I work and attend school full-time. When I am home, I am often on the computer. He used to love to play and got a lot of exercize. Now he sleeps alot (too much?) and just kinda hangs out. I have tried a bird feeder at the window, the way our building is shaped it is difficult. Not sure the landlord would allow it because I would have to remove the screen. Also don't want him to fall out if there is no screen.

He hasn't set foot on soil in over a year. Our apartment is on the 3rd floor, no patio or balcony.

Soooo, I am thinking of getting another cat. First, would it be fair to bring another cat into such a small apartment? Second, would a kitten or an older cat be best?

I think a kitten would be good because they wouldn't know the outdoors as well and may be more amiable to a new cat. I think Sebastian would be gentle with a kitten, more so than a new adult male cat.

Then I think an adult would be best because there are so many who need homes. If it were a female I think there would be a good chance they could get along unless it was a queenly one like the Siamese mix we lived with. Yet, I don't want to get one that will not get along. How awful to share a small space with someone you don't like. Plus, if I adopted an older cat, they could share the same food - wouldn't have to separate kitten and senior food.

So, if I get a kitten, would male or female be best? Is there any way to tell the temperment of an adult cat before bringing her home?

If I decide to do this, it will be a forever thing so I want to do it well.

Any advice at all would be welcome.
Thank you



This is Sebastian a couple of years ago when he had a patio.
 

larke

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 9, 2005
Messages
2,278
Purraise
6
Location
SE Canada
I think that given the space you have, unless you're prepared to keep them separated behind doors for any length of time that it might take til they're friends (and what if they're not?), you have to decide what to do if things didn't work out. Your cat is on the brink of being 'older' in cat terms, though he could be around for many more years (and your instincts about screens is good), and a new young male might well try to dominate, or a female could be on the wrong end of things, seeing as he was there first. There's no way to predict what could happen, but if you can keep them separate when you're out, til you're very sure they're friends, and have a back-up plan (other friend? shelter?) if things don't work out, it could be worth a try. He's gorgeous!
 

jaycee

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
Mar 23, 2006
Messages
926
Purraise
5
Location
Washington state
its impossible to know how a new cat will act in your apt or around your cat, even if you spend time with it before you adopt it.
i suggest getting a kitten (there will be lots of those needing homes soon with spring coming up).
 

persi & alley

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
6,313
Purraise
15
Location
Farmers Branch, Texas
Originally Posted by Bonnie1965

Hi

I have seen threads similar to this but not quite what I need to ask.

Sebastian and I live in a small studio apartment (around 300 sq ft). It isn't ideal but it is the best I can do for now.
Before we moved to this place a year ago, Sebastian was and indoor/outdoor guy. He loved going outside a few times a day to listen to the squirrels yell at him and pretend he could catch birds. At that time, we also lived with a siamese mix female cat a bit older than him. She didn't like him, he liked to play with her but since she hated him, it was tough to do.

However, he did have a girlfriend in the outside world. He was so gentle and loving with her and chased any other cats away who even thought about coming near our patio.
Yes, he has been fixed since he adopted me about 9 years ago (he is somewhere around 10 yrs old). The female he loved was also fixed.

Now, I am afraid he is lonely. I work and attend school full-time. When I am home, I am often on the computer. He used to love to play and got a lot of exercize. Now he sleeps alot (too much?) and just kinda hangs out. I have tried a bird feeder at the window, the way our building is shaped it is difficult. Not sure the landlord would allow it because I would have to remove the screen. Also don't want him to fall out if there is no screen.

He hasn't set foot on soil in over a year. Our apartment is on the 3rd floor, no patio or balcony.

Soooo, I am thinking of getting another cat. First, would it be fair to bring another cat into such a small apartment? Second, would a kitten or an older cat be best?

I think a kitten would be good because they wouldn't know the outdoors as well and may be more amiable to a new cat. I think Sebastian would be gentle with a kitten, more so than a new adult male cat.

Then I think an adult would be best because there are so many who need homes. If it were a female I think there would be a good chance they could get along unless it was a queenly one like the Siamese mix we lived with. Yet, I don't want to get one that will not get along. How awful to share a small space with someone you don't like. Plus, if I adopted an older cat, they could share the same food - wouldn't have to separate kitten and senior food.

So, if I get a kitten, would male or female be best? Is there any way to tell the temperment of an adult cat before bringing her home?

If I decide to do this, it will be a forever thing so I want to do it well.

Any advice at all would be welcome.
Thank you



This is Sebastian a couple of years ago when he had a patio.
Your Sebastian looks exactly like I expect Persi to look. Persi is still only ten months old and continues to darken. But on to the question: My daughter literally found Alley in L.A. in a dumpster in an alley. She could not keep cats in her apartment and she was so concerned about this cat that she asked if she could come live with Persi. So, what's a parent to do, we said of course, and Alley was shipped from L.A. to Dallas. Alley is about three years old or less the vet says. For the first few days, Alley would not let Persi anywhere near her, but as you can see from the center photo below, they are such great friends now. Alley does sit at the back door which is all glass and stares out into the back yard a lot of the time, she must miss the outside but I will not let either cat outside. This is not a tremendous age difference but then again, I am not too sure how well I could get along with a woman three times my age!
But Persi and Alley now get along great and I am glad that Alley has came to keep him company.
 

carolpetunia

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Oct 25, 2005
Messages
9,669
Purraise
17
Location
Plano, Texas
You're so good to put serious thought into this question. I think Larke is right, though -- there's no way to predict what will happen, so you've got to have a backup plan in place.

The easiest thing would be to adopt from a no-kill shelter that has the same policy as the one I volunteer for: if you ever have to give the kitty up, they will take her back. (This is their way of trying to ensure that adopters never abandon their cats or take them to a kill shelter.) That way, you could give them time to get used to each other... and if it just didn't work out, the new kitty would have a good safe place to go back to.

It sounds like you probably have no place to keep the new kitty separated except the bathroom, and that would be tough if the process took a whole two weeks, as the thread on this site suggests. But I was lucky -- I only had to keep my Pearl separated for four days before she and Clyde became pals! (I still separated them when I left the house, just to be safe, but I stopped even that after ten days.)

As for the age issue...I think a small kitten might be too energetic for an older fellow like your Sebastian. We brought home a little one last fall, and he drove our other cats crazy while he was developing his hunting skills!
But he's seven months old now, and he's starting to settle down just a little. Maybe a kitty around ten or twelve months would be a better companion for Sebastian.

If you could find a very laid-back older cat, that might work out better still. What if you could find, for example, a Ragdoll? From what I hear, they're extremely mellow.

Sebastian is a very handsome fellow, by the way!
 
Top