Thanks, everybody. I've got a nice long list to bring on my next cat food expedition. I have high hopes for the Nutro sliced turkey because she loves turkey but I couldn't find it anywhere locally. I might go ahead and order a case on Amazon but it's a big commitment in case it doesn't work out!
I've been avoiding all chicken just to be safe.
I tried the Pride lamb last night and duck this morning and she wouldn't touch either one. The cat who can eat any old food loved them. Of course.
I know this is the holy grail, but I'm looking for a chicken-free non-pâté-style canned cat food that I can afford. Years ago my cats ate Merrick Thanksgiving Day Dinner and Cowboy Cookout, but now the former contains chicken and the latter is not very healthy.
I tried feeding dry food since...