I had the same problem, I now use Nature's Variety Instinct Limited Ingredient.. It comes in a few flavours, I use the rabbit.
For canned, I use BFF, as it has no chicken in some of them. I usually get the seafood ones.
A little late, but I ordered this one from all pet furniture and free shipping.
http://www.allpetfurniture.com/Armarkat-B7801-ATM1027.html?refid=EH&mmid=66406878&csnid=538C8352-D31C-4967-82C6-035E5860B3CA
Thanks for the feedback everyone.
Yes, indeed, I found it's made by the same company that makes Wellness.
After doing some searching and being in Canada, using Mr. Chewy may be the best route for me.
I can pick it up just over the border so shipping is free. They have a great selection of...
It's a brand at one of the pet stores in my area and it's not too badly priced.
Here's a link to their website if anyone wants to see it, I'm curious as to what you think of the quality.
http://holisticselect.com/recipes.aspx?pet=cat
Thanks