Pros: It's kitty crack. Whatever's in these things, cats love them
Cons: Treat only, Temptations aren't a replacement for regular cat food
My cat doesn't seem to distinguish between regular temptations and this alternative, which is supposed to include added minerals and be free of preservatives. As with most cat food, it's difficult to accurately gauge health effects, but what I can say is that this is among Bud's favorite snacks, and he's a healthy, energetic little guy. He loves the chicken flavors, surfer's delight and beef.
FYI: If you're a Costco member, look for these in your local store. I bought a two-pack of big, 16oz tubs of these things. (Regular bags are 3oz.) As with anything in Costco, you pay a bit more and get a lot more, for value over time. In my local Costco the two-packs are varieties, so you can get two different flavors in each 2-pack.